3 ms·
Looking at the LEGO diagram, here's one thing that's "more to this" that isn't stated: shape. When I saw the problem description, my natural inclination was to
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Looking at the LEGO diagram, here's one thing that's "more to this" that isn't stated: shape.
When I saw the problem description, my natural inclination was to add a support brick in a way that doesn't stick out, to stabilize roof in that direction without altering the building's appearance from both ground level (how the action figures would see it) and air level (how a human would see it). Remove that main pillar instead, and the building is now a meaningfully different one. Additive solution feels much less invasive, and it's something I'd default for in real life, on the assumption the original architects / owners liked the existing looks, and would prefer it not to be visibly altered.
Of course, I then thought, "since looks are technically not a part of the problem definition, I could solve it by removing the middle brick" - but that's my software engineering experience kicking in. The way this thought feels is the same as if I discovered a neat work-minimizing hack when writing code, or in general, how I feel when solving logic puzzles. But in logic puzzles, I already know the whole point is to find the solutions that feel clever.
I think people do have some natural, subconscious intuition for Chesterton's fence - for minimizing unknown unknowns. And to shut it off, it takes more than just saying "removing bricks are allowed", you need to convince them to switch their thinking into puzzle mode, make them explicitly discount the solutions that feel obvious.
- anigbrowl 6y agoIt seems kinda ironic to me that you're arguing for people being wired a certain way when the outcome of this (and the other experiments, which involved sandwich recipes) seems to point to the fact that people are not wired the same. I default to the opposite position of yours, ie taking the problem exactly as stated. Indeed, I find it quite challenging when posing some sort of hypothetical to people (eg in debate) and they import additional considerations rather than addressing an issue as stated - although this paper and this conversation give me a better understanding of why that might be.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYou're right, I jumped to conclusions in the last paragraph. I definitely shouldn't assume people are wired the same. I myself am not exactly "neurotypical", so I know it first-hand. So I'll revise my position to: based on my personal experience, observing people I know and general impression I get from reading and hearing things, I believe there is a non-trivial subset of the population, of which I'm a member, that has a sort of subconscious intuition for Chesterton's fence, and do not, by default, take problems at face value.
- anigbrowl 6y agoI hope they'll build on this research as there are benefits and costs to both thinking styles, and as you say there could be great value in knowing which when to make use of which thinking mode, rather than designating one as The Right Way and expecting people to always use it. By the way I think you might find this paper of interest - about social dilemmas rather than cognitive styles, but I wonder if the results might not be rooted in the same sort of implicit assumption/intuition that you're positing. https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600451 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600451