4 ms·
The WWWorst App Store
- stephc_int13 6y agoI feel the same about web apps. the web is great for documents and even better of collaborative documents like Wikipedia. But the so called "thin-client" model can easily turn into a nigthmare from a privacy / individual freedom point of view.
- Seirdy 6y agoSaaS is a good example of the difference between free software and open source. If some software is freely licensed but still a closed platform dependent on a particular client implementation and server provider (e.g. the web apps the article describes, Signal/Telegram/etc), that thing is nonfree despite being open source.
- yakubin 6y agoThe suggestion at the end is a more drastic version of what is done at <https://flak.tedunangst.com/ https://flak.tedunangst.com/>. I prefer the latter for the added artistic aspect. :)
- SahAssar 6y agoOn the other hand, without web apps I'm pretty sure I couldn't daily drive linux since most companies don't care enough to build apps for linux and even if they did I'd rather not have to install an app for every tool/service I use. I think this article is all wrong. Using the web as an app platform means that people can use any OS that runs a modern web browser. It is also possible to package web apps as offline capable apps (either via service-workers or just files opened with file:// like classic HTA's).
- selfhoster11 6y agoWeb browsers usurped the OS layer and displaced the local OS (Mac, Linux, Windows) into the layer where the hypervisor traditionally used to be. The real OS is Google Chrome/Firefox, and your local OS is just a para(?)virtualisation/driver layer. That's not a victory for Linux, though it does mean that it becomes a better daily driver than it was before web apps took over.
- SahAssar 6y agoIf we take what you said as fact it means that the "OS layer" is more standardized and more compatible between platforms. It means that we have a common target that works for both FOSS users (FF/Chromium on linux) and for closed platforms (Edge on Win, Safari on OSX) and even the two large mobile platforms. In that way it levels the playing field and gives FOSS platforms a better chance. How many of the people who daily drive linux today do you think could have if the web was only a text/document consumption platform? At least in the group of people I know it would be far less.
- domano 6y agoI think modern web apps alleviate a lot of these issues if done right. They can function without internet since they can contain and persist a local version of the required data. Oftentimes you can save it locally and _eventually_ sync with the server. Legally, at least in the EU, you can request at least all personally identifiable information in a standard compliant or easily readable format. API based clients also theoretically allow for easy fetching of data, which you can then in turn persist in any way you like. Still, for the average user, most of the times you are at the mercy of the SaaS provider. I think a legal requirement for standard-compliant data export would be nice.
- selfhoster11 6y ago> They can function without internet since they can contain and persist a local version of the required data. Local persistence is treated with derision because browsers can arbitrarily empty it at any moment. The only way to work around this is Electron, as far as I know, and that's a native application more or less. > API based clients also theoretically allow for easy fetching of data The focus being theoretically. APIs are often locked behind paywalls/partner keys, and sometimes obfuscated.