3 ms·
I certainly agree the motivations of the people attending are a problem. But again, it's systemic. Locke and Spender cover it well. You keep being sure about T
by wpietri 6y ago
I certainly agree the motivations of the people attending are a problem. But again, it's systemic. Locke and Spender cover it well.
You keep being sure about Toyota without any knowledge. That's very MBA of you, but I don't think it advances the discussion. The executives who turned it into a global power were engineers. And that engineering orientation was vital to the creation of the Toyota Way. Deeply influenced by W Edwards Deming, an engineer and statistician.
Nobody is denying that "boring" things like finance are important. Indeed, I'm saying the opposite. My point is that giving somebody a quick education that covers many "boring" things in a shallow fashion is not a great way to create executives. It is a great way, though, to create a glib executive caste that is good at extracting cash. Which is why executive comp has risen massively over the decades even though few would argue that executives are massively more competent.
You might be right that the MBA is better for people who have already developed actual expertise. But the average age of Harvard MBA applicants is 27, and only 12% are over 30. So if you're correct, then we can at least agree that most MBA grads shouldn't be in charge of anything.