4 ms·
> I'm giving the argument to remove the income tax, not to remove government completely. Then maybe you shouldn't be calling other people "statists". Especial
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> I'm giving the argument to remove the income tax, not to remove government completely.
Then maybe you shouldn't be calling other people "statists". Especially you shouldn't be using it as a put-down or a condescending dismissal.
> Before the income tax & before the FED, the world had unmatched growth.
It also had unmatched financial crises every decade or so. (Yeah, I know, we had the Great Depression with the Fed existing. We also had the mess in 2008. That's one and a half in a hundred years. That's a far cry from where we were without the Fed.) So maybe don't trumpet how wonderful everything was pre-1913, because it had a downside that destroyed a lot of people.
- briantakita 6y ago> Then maybe you shouldn't be calling other people "statists". Especially you shouldn't be using it as a put-down or a condescending dismissal. He started it by trying to put me down as being a Libertarian. Statist is an accurate term. It's only a put-down because when you look at it, it's a self-serving & ultimately abusive position. I don't need to try very hard b/c it's obvious that the statist position is ultimately about a tranfer of wealth from the people who do the real work of making the world better to the people who want to control others. > It also had unmatched financial crises every decade or so There was a feedback loop, often based on speculation & financialization. > That's one and a half in a hundred years You forgot the S&L crash in 1986, the dot com bust, the housing bust, the neverending & accelerating QE (money printing), etc. The current fiat petrol-dollar paradigm, that directly perpetuated neverending wars, is crashing around us as we speak. > So maybe don't trumpet how wonderful everything was pre-1913, because it had a downside that destroyed a lot of people. I fail to see how the invention & propagation of electricity & sanitation leading to the rapid increase in life expectancy and unprecedented increase in real (as opposed to fiat, which is another blunder of statists) wealth, "destroyed a lot of people". You have an argument that certain aspects of industralization & centralization had negative effects on the human. However, the positive aspects of our growth & transcendence of previous poverty was due to the spirit of human ingenuity & the collective energy of the population to improve their lives & the lives around them. Governments only (with few exceptions) got in the way of this progress.
- bumby 6y ago>He started it by trying to put me down as being a Libertarian. Besides the "he started it" being a weak argument, I never claimed you were a Libertarian. There is a world of difference in saying, "the ideas you're talking about fall in line with libertarianism" and saying "you are a Libertarian". The latter treads closely to ad hominem fallacy. >the housing bust Is this distinct from the sub-prime crisis they already alluded to in their post? >neverending & accelerating QE (money printing) Again, this is almost always phrased in terms of inflation and to reiterate it has not yet happened despite people claiming for the last decade that it was just around the corner. Inflation may still happen but what I'm trying to get at is: if inflation turns out to not be the problem do you have another case against fiat currency? >propagation of electricity The early days of this were quite literally a mess which is why the government began instituting regulated monopolies. >transcendence of previous poverty was due to the spirit of human ingenuity & the collective energy of the population to improve their lives & the lives around them. Governments only (with few exceptions) got in the way of this progress. Citation rather than glossy overtures are strongly needed here
- briantakita 6y ago> Is this distinct from the sub-prime crisis they already alluded to in their post? Perhaps. There have been more than one... > Inflation may still happen but what I'm trying to get at is: if inflation turns out to not be the problem do you have another case against fiat currency? Inflation is already here. Cost of living, rent, gas, food, lumber, taxes, etc. are rising today. Coupled with the government mandated shutdown, particularly of select "non-essential" (aka small) business, we saw a large contraction in the economy. The government's official numbers are self-serving & moving goal-posts. http://www.shadowstats.com/ http://www.shadowstats.com/ measures the economic numbers according to benchmarks consistent with the past. Inflation is here & has been here for a while. > The early days of this were quite literally a mess which is why the government began instituting regulated monopolies. It was even more of a mess before the invention of electricity. The regulation of utilities could be considered a success. At least the government did one thing right. Problem is despite the Trillions going into taxes over the years, we have a grid that is vulnerable to long term blackouts. With the Grand Solar Minimum being here & a geomagnetic excursion occurring, we can expect space weather to create more issues (e.g. Carrington Event). We are also vulnerable to CME attacks caused by foreign governments. Not good. > Citation rather than glossy overtures are strongly needed here My citation is the amount of time that people have to spend working to pay taxes & their unhappiness in doing so. Who makes things happen in everyday life? The citizenry/people, not bureaucrats.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]