Consider TB and bcg vaccine. This is very real problem and very good example. In perfect society every person should decide for themselves whether to get bcg v

Consider TB and bcg vaccine. This is very real problem and very good example. In perfect society every person should decide for themselves whether to get bcg vaccine for oneself and their children like, every day of their lives. Being responsible for their actions, they should argue, before broad society, that they knowingly and willingly, being fully informed about dangers of tuberculosis disease and full scientific consensus about this terrible disease and best current methods of containing, preventing and curing it: 1) endanger themselves by not using vaccinations This seriously compromises their right to live, work, and have children 2) endanger to substantial amount every other person around them This applies not only to vaccinations, but to regular checks, preventative measures, etc as well. Serious violation of rights of other people to live, be healthy, work, have children, ... 3) endanger children, especially from socially vulnerable groups 4) endanger their own children, in case they do not vaccinate them So, in perfectly informed society where every contagious illness is traced to it's origin, this person should bear blame for every piece of suffering which them caused. Freedom and rights do not mean freedom to and right to cause suffering. So, the first step of retribution and correcting injustice will be, first, correct the source of error, meaning forcing person to use vaccine (and other measures). He still should have an option to take control of his own life and deny vaccination (we are talking about perfect society) and choose complete exile and isolation for rest of his life instead. Like, equivalent of his death to all other people. One could argue that the very act of endangering other person, especially a child, is still criminal and probabilistic suffering should be punished too, if probability is high enough, and TB - bcg is good example, because vaccine is shown to be hugely beneficent. Even regular TB is nigh incurable, and cure for AB resistant TB does not exist, so current epidemic is arguably a problem. Of course, real life differ from ideal picture. We just short-circuit all this logic and give bcg to every child born without asking questions. And while parent can say no, this means voluntary exile, no school, no university, no work, etc.