5 ms·
It always seems we have a certain bias when it comes to imagining alien civilizations more advanced than our own and that their energy needs would somehow be th
by throwaway_kufu 6y ago
It always seems we have a certain bias when it comes to imagining alien civilizations more advanced than our own and that their energy needs would somehow be the same, similar, or greater than our own. Ignoring gravitational differences of various potential origin planets and the energy requirement differences to get into orbit based on a given planet’s gravity fields...what if the beings themselves were many orders of magnitude smaller or larger (or both for that matter). Even here on earth imagine some other beings with all the capabilities as us but could essentially stretch their arms upward and place little old us into orbit without the need for propulsion, or other beings so microscopic we could never be capable of detecting them even if they had the capability of building craft that could escape Earth’s gravity field.
- Larrikin 6y agoAre you referring to Dragons egg or just imagining the plot independently?
- Sharlin 6y agoThe only assumption made here is ambition, and it is explicitly stated. An ambitious civilization will figure out a use for whatever amount of harvestable energy is available. Computation, if nothing else. The paper is about upper bounds; whether any civilization can (or wants to) actually reach anywhere near them is another question for another paper.