2 ms·
I still don't see one bit of explanation as to how an analogy is equivalent to a material conditional. I agree that Derek's analogy was poorly chosen for his a
by philwelch 15y ago
I still don't see one bit of explanation as to how an analogy is equivalent to a material conditional.
I agree that Derek's analogy was poorly chosen for his audience. Clearly, he should have anticipated that people would be pedantic enough to bikeshed over whether or not fish actually realize they are in water.
- ColinWright 15y agoI can't speak for your original interlocutor, but for me, it went like this: Fish don't know about water ... Hang on. Firstly, you don't know that. Secondly, it's plausible that some do. OK, I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Is this a premise? An analogy? Either way it's either wrong or pretty weak - why should I bother reading the rest? I mean, if it's all this bad, then it'll be a waste of time ... Perhaps someone else's thought processes go like this: If this is an analogy it's really poor, so I guess it must be a premise. But it's wrong, so now I really don't know what's going on here ... It reads like a starting point. It reads like a fact that will be built on. To some, that's bad, and possibly jerrya was just trying to point that out. From that point of view it is, perhaps, you who is bikeshedding. Perhaps you should take jerrya's comment slightly less literally, and more as you would have us read the original article. But that's just how it seems to me. Likely I'm wrong too. But one thing's now for sure, I've expressed my views, and I'm unlikely to spend more time on this question. http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/
- philwelch 15y agoSo you can't be bothered to read more than five words before formulating an opinion, yet you write several paragraphs expressing that opinion. And then you downvote me for asking how an analogy equates to a material conditional?
- ColinWright 15y agoInteresting how you assume I downvoted you. I didn't. Research shows that opinions are formed very, very quickly. Further, I did read the article, even though my initial reactions were so negative. I did that because I know that sometimes people don't write well, but their ideas might still be worth considering. My comments were born of trying to help people understand how apparently small issues in their writing can have apparently disproportionate effects on their audiences. So, let's see. You said: So you can't be bothered to read more than five words That was wrong. ... before formulating an opinion, Your outrage contradicts findings in research. ... yet you write several paragraphs expressing that opinion. Yes. Clear expression of ideas matters, and sometimes the "instant quip" is a bad way to get an idea across. And then you downvote me No, I didn't. ... for asking how an analogy equates to a material conditional? But that wasn't the point. I tried to explain how there were multiple ways to look at that opening "idea," and that none of them actually worked. So clearly I've failed in getting my point across. As Samuel Johnson said (although other sources attribute it to James Boswell): Sir, I have found you an argument; but I am not obliged to find you an understanding.
- philwelch 15y agoI conceded your point before you wasted your time arguing it. Past that point, you've really nothing interesting to say. Sadly, I am more than familiar with the general quality of people's reading comprehension. Perhaps it is too much to expect that someone reads something and understands it before formulating an opinion about it. By the way, statements like this Your outrage contradicts findings in research. are curious as well. My "outrage" (disappointment, really) is a sentiment, not a proposition. Which raises an interesting question--you criticize a metaphor, essentially a parable, by attacking its literal and logical truth, while spouting logical nonsense of your own. I criticize your logic, and you fall back to...what, exactly? Incidentally, there's no proof either way whether you downvoted me or not, but I will take you at your word and disregard the circumstantial evidence otherwise.
- ColinWright 15y agoI conceded your point before you wasted your time arguing it. Past that point, you've really nothing interesting to say. My apologies for wasting your time. It wasn't clear to me that you understood the points I was trying to make. It now does seem clear to me that you don't, but since I've already said it as clearly as I can, seems little point in adding to it. You may choose not to bother reading further. >> Your outrage contradicts findings in research. > My "outrage" (disappointment, really) is a > sentiment, not a proposition. Sorry, but it seemed to me to be more than simply disappointment. And you may be disappointed, but research says that people form opinions very quickly. To try to take a stance that this should not be the case is a little odd. So I guess I don't understand your point. > ... spouting logical nonsense of your own. It's not clear to me what of my writings you think are logical nonsense. It's also not clear what you refer to when you say: "I criticize your logic ..." I've re-read your comments several time, and don't really see a coherent criticism of my logic. Thank you for taking me at my word when I say I didn't down-vote you. I don't down-vote people for simple disagreements. But let me finish with this: Yes, it was an analogy. Yes, he was using it to set the scene to make a valid point. Yes, the article was mildly insightful. The point I was trying to make - no doubt badly - is that his leading statement just provoked the reaction: Well, that's wrong. As such, as a rhetorical device, it was particularly badly chosen. Some members of his readership were always going to react badly to it because it's possibly wrong. The points you and I are discussing here are the true bikeshedding. Whether one should interpret such statements logically, literally, or however is not the point. Analogies should be chosen carefully lest they distract from the point, rather than enhance it. This discussion essentially proves that point.