3 ms·
I wonder how much a gateway router can do here. Most of the data passing it are encrypted: https, SSH. Cutting off the phone-home requests is best done on res
by nine_k 6y ago
I wonder how much a gateway router can do here.
Most of the data passing it are encrypted: https, SSH.
Cutting off the phone-home requests is best done on respective devices: you can run firewalls on most desktops and laptops, and even phones. Рhones often go online via GSM or LTE, without passing through the home router.
While a proxy like pihole can be helpful sometimes, cutting off tracking and ads is done best by browser extensions and by using open-source clients, where available.
The best the home router should do is to not be vulnerable to exploits, and otherwise up-to-date, and fully under the owner's control That's why my home router runs openwrt.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"I wonder how much a gateway router can do here." "... cutting off tracking and ads is best done by browser extensions ..." What if the browser vendor, who is also a data collector, requires user to log in or otherwise identify herself before she can use extensions. A home "gateway" is a computer running a kernel with IP forwarding enabled that is being used as the point of egress from the home network to the internet. That is a broad definition and allows for much creativity. That is what I mean by the term "gateway". As such, a gateway can, both in theory and in practice, do anything/nothing that "desktops and laptops, and even phones" can do. Relying solely on pre-configured "limited/special purpose" OS projects as a replacement for DIY and creativity in setting up a gateway was not what I had in mind, but is certainly an option amongst many others.
- nine_k 6y agoDon't use such a browser then! Firefox is pretty good. An on-device firewall can firewall individual processes and applications. An upstream / gateway firewall does not have such fine-grained control. That was my point. Running stuff on my router is entirely possible, but I limit it to routing and running a wireguard endpoint. I prefer to run my private stuff in the confines of the home LAN.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Don't use such a browser then!" Never said that I did! :) I use a text-only browser for reading HTML. Many times I do even use a browser for making HTTP requests. Truly one can use all these strategies, application-based, router-based, gateway-based, if they are available. They are not mutually exclusive. Personally I just would not feel like I can rely on extensions or other solutions tied to some software I do not compile myself. (I do edit and compile the text-only browser.) All due respect to Firefox, but I have found compiling it is way too time and resource-intensive. It is way beyond what I need for recreational web use. Firefox users seem to rely on Mozilla to do the right things on their behalf. That is not the sort of "control by the user" I am after. What is behind Mozilla. Online advertising money. Cannot really count on them to do what I want.
- Hedepig 6y ago> I use a text-only browser for reading HTML. Is that getting more difficult with the prevelance of JavaScript driven websites?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoFor me it has not. But it all depends on what sites one is interested in. Generally I do not tend to find much value in SPAs when I come across them. If there is some data accessed through the page that I really am interested in, I just fnd the endpoint and bypass the Javascript. Most sites posted to HN are not SPAs, do not require Javascript to read, and work perfectly for me. I can glean the information no problem, and fast. However I am interesting reading text not viewing graphics. Not every user has the same sensibilities.
- speedcoder 6y agoWhat text only browser do you use?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoI have always aimed to try them all and I will always try any new one I become aware of. I used Lynx from 1993 through the early 2000's, but since then I prefer Links from Charles University in Prague, with no graphics. It has the best rendering of HTML tables of any text-only browser, IMO. It has been the most stable for me at run-time and it is the source code I am most comfortable with, compiles quickly. There is a recent fork of Elinks 4.x someone has started that I have been watching. (Elinks is a fork of Links.) Not sure if it has been posted to HN yet. Currently it crashes too easily but some of the features he has added are good ideas, IMO.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]