5 ms·
"Tech workers have it great. What would a union even accomplish?" Stuff like this is exactly what unions would accomplish if they became more standard in the i
by paxys 6y ago
"Tech workers have it great. What would a union even accomplish?"
Stuff like this is exactly what unions would accomplish if they became more standard in the industry. The Google union is a couple months old and is already successfully defending their members from violations of labor laws. How many others are there who are working in unsafe conditions and/or illegally fired for "security reasons" and have no one to speak out on their behalf?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI think this discussion of unions for tech workers glosses over a fundamental truth. While a union may be good for some people, for many (I think most) technical experts at a place like Google it would easily be a net negative, so they don't want them. A similar analogy is why "no-tipping" restaurants are so rare in the US (or why they go away so quickly when they are tried). While no-tipping may benefit some servers, your good and better servers can easily make more money with tipping, so they don't want it to go away. The same dynamic exists for software developers.
- gowld 6y agoServers like tipping because big tippers are more than the enforced average of non-tippers. It's little to do with the people being tipped, and the people who make the most tips are the ones with the largest breasts and prettiest makeup and skin color, not the ones doing the best job waiting tables.
- onethought 6y agoOr you could just increase minimum wage (unions help with that!) and get rid of tipping culture. Because fucking with peoples livelihood because your muffin took a bit long to come out is insane.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI mean, this seems to completely miss my point. Good servers make much, much more than minimum wage.
- ddingus 6y agoCAN make more. Not so many of them actually do.
- Aunche 6y agoMost career waiters make more money from tips than wages. Customers are willing to pay more when they know exactly where their money is going.
- ddingus 6y agoThat's not most waiters. Tipping sucks. The expectation that people work a full time job that does not also carry the expectation of being able to fund them existing and continuing to show up for work sucks too. You've made the same, "but a few are doing great" argument made above.
- Aunche 6y agoIf a waiter makes less than minimum wage from tips, the restaurant has to make up the difference. In these situations, the restaurant's margins are so thin that they'd be receiving minimum wage anyways.
- ipaddr 6y agoNo union is perfect for an environment without management. Introduce management and a union is required.
- kortilla 6y agoWhat exactly is it you think makes a union “required”? I’ve not worked for a single union company in my tech career and everything appeared to be better at every company than pretty much any other industry that I know of.
- FpUser 6y ago>"everything appeared to be better at every company than pretty much any other industry that I know of." Maybe if you held different position your point of view on a subject could be different.
- gretch 6y agoYeah maybe. You can say “maybe” anything... Are this person’s experiences not valid on their own somehow?
- ddingus 6y agoMaybe, just maybe, those of us working in great conditions can give more weight to the many more who clearly are not, lest we all see a reduction?
- Retric 6y agoA great many people spent a great deal of time and effort making unions seem like a bad deal. However, the underlying truth is unions are till useful for Actors making millions of dollars on a movie let alone FAANG programmers. The core misunderstanding is unions adjust to the conditions of the workers they represent. Collective bargaining is hated by upper management because it shifts more power to the workforce be that someone making minimum wage or millions. People think great healthcare when they should be thinking more worker friendly stock vesting schedules and other issues that impact highly compensated individuals.
- jariel 6y agoUnions have no value for 'actors making millions'. The union is basically irrelevant to them. The various unions and guilds in film/tv production are there to protect the regular workers who operate in often very irregular and ad-hoc circumstances. Also - acting is a hugely oversubscribed job, most actors don't do acting full time. There are 10 actors for every role. Even good one's. Even just 'working actor' - let alone 'millions' - is a very lucky position. 'Famous' actors are not helped by the union, they have agents who manage their deals, much like athletes and their comp. is a function of totally different things. 'Athlete's Unions' are actually advantageous to them, because they can leverage power against owners, but in that case it's 'rich' vs. 'rich' entities fighting over surpluses, and nothing is gained or lost for the rest of us, it's not a helpful basis of comparison for working-class unions.
- Retric 6y ago‘Famous’ actors making millions like Donald Trump joined the SAG because they thought it was a net benefit to them. One of the major benefits is protection from those vary same managers which have historically often acted in their own interest rather than their clients. Another benefit that seems minor to multi millionaires but occasion really makes a huge difference in these people’s lives is a significant pension. It’s unfortunately common for very rich actors to end up broke at some point making the security of knowing you’re never going to be poor even if they don’t stay rich a huge deal. That’s something managers can’t negotiate on a film by film basis and it’s an example where minimizing downsides becomes more valuable than maximizing total compensation.
- Spooky23 6y agoYeah... those fast casual restaurants and cafeterias are just unable to compete. I’ve worked with big tech companies as a customer for a long time on significant projects. Over time, corporate politics is pretty brutal and without representation good people get into lousy situations, even for high performers. Google is no exception.
- tdeck 6y agoMy understanding of the relevant research is that tipping is not strongly related to service quality. Most people tip the same everywhere, perhaps varying according to their mood or the type of establishment. It's certainly not a given that "good and better" servers are making more from tips.
- worik 6y agoAnd the article demonstrates not all tech workers have it great, aye?
- Macha 6y agoAlthough software engineers and systems administrators do have it great now, compared to others like the data center techs in this article, it is also worth planning for a time that it may not be so, especially if you expect to be in the industry for a long time yet.
- haolez 6y agoCome work here in Brazil! We have more than 15,000 unions! We have a union for union workers (not even joking). It's great! We are now a very very rich country, the labor is valued and we are also a tech powerhouse! Sarcasm aside, it's really disturbing to see amazing countries like the USA falling for the same illusions that have kept us poor since forever. What defeats bad bosses is the option for workers to simply walk away, be it because of competitors offering better conditions or because you don't really need the income in the short term. If your are left wing inclined, I suggest that you lobby UBI instead of unions. Be better than us.
- triceratops 6y agocorrelation != causation. I can give you examples of rich countries that have lots of unions. Would you say it's the unions that made them rich? You should look elsewhere for reasons why Brazil is relatively poor today. I guarantee you unions have very little to do with it.
- erklik 6y ago> I can give you examples of rich countries that have lots of unions. Just curious, who would that be? I am guessing some Scandinavian countries, maybe?
- smnrchrds 6y agoSee the table here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_agreement_coverage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_agreement_coverage France, Austria, Belgium, Iceland, and Sweden all have above 90% collective bargaining coverage. Finland, Denmark, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Australia, Luxembourg, Switzerland, and Germany are between 50% and 90%.
- ipaddr 6y agoImagine life without your unions. It could be worse. Brazil has many problems preventing it from taking over the globe. Union are not holding them back. You have bigger companies vs many smaller companies. Unions and big companies go hand in hand.
- ageek123 6y agoWhy is the Alphabet Workers Union filing lawsuits on behalf of people who don't work for Alphabet (e.g. the woman in this article)?
- kortilla 6y agoBecause it’s a political group, not a traditional union. Its members are more interested in control over the company and perceived injustices to others rather than problems experienced by the members. Collective bargaining can be used to make demands about anything really. It doesn’t have to be working conditions for workers. They can even use their power to pressure Google into supporting particular political candidates, etc if they have enough power.
- skratlo 6y agoWow, just wow. Like, no one asked really but here you go
- Craighead 6y agoWhat is stated is absolutely true...
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThat's one perspective, though you haven't attempted to demonstrate why politicals shouldn't be an aspect of unions. Seems reasonable to me for unions to be involved in lobbying.
- istjohn 6y agoRight. We accept that corporations lobby constantly. Why shouldn't their employees have a voice, too?
- jariel 6y agoAnyone should be able to lobby. There's nothing overtly nefarious about lobbying. Lobbying is 'telling government about something specific'. Usually in your own interests, but the interests of the people should interest the government. The problem is the asymmetry of power and access.
- jonas21 6y agoWait, what exactly did the union accomplish here? From the article it sounds like: 1. They got a suspension for talking about unions overturned, but not her later firing over the Facebook post. 2. Google signed a document saying its employees "have the right to discuss wage rates, bonuses, and working conditions," which is just a restatement of U.S. law. 3. Nobody admitted any wrongdoing and there was no monetary compensation. If that's what winning looks like, I hate to see what losing is.
- paxys 6y ago> Her suspension for talking about supporting a union was overturned, but not her later firing for the Facebook post. Where does it say that? The article doesn't mention a firing at all. > Nobody admitted any wrongdoing and there was no monetary compensation. There usually is monetary compensation in settlements like this, they just don't disclose it.
- jonas21 6y ago> "The next day, I was at work, I got called into a conference room with all, for the most, the managers present. And they told me that my Facebook post was in violation of the non-disclosure agreement, and that I was a security risk and needed to hand over my badge and my laptop immediately, and be escorted off site." I've never been fired before, but I'm pretty sure when they ask you for your badge and laptop and escort you out the door, you're being fired.
- paxys 6y agoThis was the suspension, and is what triggered the union to file lawsuits on her behalf
- kortilla 6y ago> There usually is monetary compensation in settlements like this, they just don't disclose it. They do usually say “settled for an undisclosed sum”.