4 ms·
You're thinking of it like a legal process. Think of a private party instead - you're happy to invite lots of people, but everyone heard Adam was a real asshole
by viraptor 6y ago
You're thinking of it like a legal process. Think of a private party instead - you're happy to invite lots of people, but everyone heard Adam was a real asshole to someone in public, so you don't want to have him at the party anymore (even though he was never bad at your previous parties specifically).
It's a reasonable thing to do and you have about the same level of responsibility for your party as twitch has for their platform. You probably also don't care what the justice system thinks about the invitations to your party.
- refenestrator 6y agoI don't have the power to ban Adam from all parties. Twitch effectively does, in this case.
- fwip 6y agoThere are many services that let you livestream. Twitch is just one of the most popular.
- viraptor 6y agoYou mean they can ban someone from YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and all other services with live streaming option? That's not really the case.
- refenestrator 6y agoThere are posts elsewhere indicating that twitch is close to the only game in town for live game streaming. People were denied access to tournaments, not intending to stream or commentate themselves, because the tourney organizers wanted to stream on twitch. Sure, it's just video games, but we have to reckon in general with the consequences of an oligopoly that's 'just exercising control over their private property' when it adds up to most digital communications.
- TameAntelope 6y agoIf it’s important enough, the government should run it. Game live-streaming isn’t important enough.
- viraptor 6y agoSure, it sucks that twitch is the only game in town for professional gamers. For some reason other attempts never worked long term. But what options are there? Either it needs to be worth for someone to compete with the service, or streamers would have to gain some kind of law protection status which would be worse than now. Or even worse, twitch could go the way of pro physical sports where as long as you don't kill someone, nobody cares. (and you may even get positive pr to keep covered up)
- akira2501 6y ago> Think of a private party instead The extent to which corporations should be considered private entities does not seem like a settled question to me. Your corporation has no natural right to exist, and therefore does not have the natural right to do business solely as it pleases. > and you have about the same level of responsibility for your party as twitch has for their platform. What responsibility are they exercising? If the behavior on their platform is not disruptive to it, then what precisely are they defending their users _from_? > You probably also don't care what the justice system thinks about the invitations to your party. Invite someone on the most wanted list. I can't imagine it playing out that well for you.
- viraptor 6y ago> If the behavior on their platform is not disruptive to it, then what precisely are they defending their users _from_? From being surrounded by Adams. Either you act in cases like that, or you become known as "that place that likes to invite Adam (and others)". And it's completely up to the host which side they want to be on. Twitch chose to end the invitation. > Invite someone on the most wanted list. That's not even close to the case discussed here.
- DarkByte8 6y agoThe problem is who judges the Adams and decide that they are assholes. People are worried that the judge will not be fair and it will be biased in favor of some ideology.
- viraptor 6y agoOf course at some point it will not be fair. No system is and people make mistakes. The question is - is it going to be less fair / more biased than not applying the same policy.
- thephyber 6y agoHonest question: is there an exhaustive list of natural rights? The only ones I know about are related to the Declaration of Independence and I don’t have any evidence they are comprehensive. I don’t have any evidence to believe of a conscious higher power, so my list of natural rights is likely to differ from people who do.
- insert_coin 6y agoThey are deciding how they view each user and their actions. Shouldn't I also be expected to have the same privilege? If I want to see it like a legal process there is nothing they can say, specially after this, to make me change my outlook in the same way they ban people for violating their way of thinking and give them no appeal not even the time of day.
- viraptor 6y agoYou do have that privilege. Why do you think you don't?