3 ms·
Making heterogenous individual packs sounds like an absolute disaster. That's why this is various car companies teaming up with specific folk: because they'll h
by rektide 6y ago
Making heterogenous individual packs sounds like an absolute disaster. That's why this is various car companies teaming up with specific folk: because they'll have big quantities of cells from each individual vehicle they get, and there will only be so many different types of cell. There will be big supplies of a couple different cells, ready to go in to applications of all different sorts.
As it so happens, there's already a lot of agreement. Many many cells are either 18 mm, 21mm or 28 mm diameter cylinders & 650-700 mm long. "18650" cell is very common. 28650 used to be a "big" cell but it's not around as much I feel like. "2170" is a "21700" that is increasingly popular. Most of these cells have similar charge behavior, of applying a fixed amps up to a point, perhaps with temperature sensors to detect problems/slow down, and then a slower finishing charge, that ends around 4.2V per cell.
Using solar grid-tie micro-inverters would probably work fine to join together a bunch of different packs.
- Reason077 6y agoAnd now, Tesla are developing an even bigger "4680" cell: https://evannex.com/blogs/news/tesla-s-4680-cell-is-a-stroke-of-genius-sandy-munro https://evannex.com/blogs/news/tesla-s-4680-cell-is-a-stroke...
- CyanLite4 6y agoA little too much fanboyism with that link.
- barney54 6y agoOnly Tesla uses cylindrical cells such as 18650s or 2170s. The other EV makers use prismatic cells or pouch cells.
- rektide 6y agoI'd meant to mention pouch/prismatic cells, thanks. I had been under the impression that some of the big manufacturers had started using cylindrical cells, but I can't seem to find any evidence. Oops!
- ta20210405 6y agoThis is incorrect. Rivian also uses 2170s.
- tape_measure 6y agoAn 18650 is 65mm long. I think "eighteen six fifty" is more euphonic than "eighteen sixty five". A 2170 is 70mm long
- Syonyk 6y ago> Using solar grid-tie micro-inverters would probably work fine to join together a bunch of different packs. No, they won't. The voltage range is all wrong for a full pack (microinverters work on one or two panels, so a normal working range of 30-80V, usually 50-60V per panel open circuit), and they tend to operate at their maximum power point. You'd have far better luck with string inverters that can operate in that range (a typical residential string inverter will work from 200V to 600VDC which is just perfect for EV packs), and with a few modifications, you could get one that allows control over the output power (I expect some have that already, I'm just not sure which ones might).
- elihu 6y ago> No, they won't. The voltage range is all wrong for a full pack (microinverters work on one or two panels, so a normal working range of 30-80V, usually 50-60V per panel open circuit), and they tend to operate at their maximum power point. Actually, that sounds just about right, if you're working with modules rather than full packs. Tesla has various sizes of battery module, but 57 volts is one common size. (I think a typical model S has somewhere around 14 of them.) So, one microinverter per module would be fine. LG Chem also makes a module that's about 60 volts. (I think it's made up of around 16 pouch cells in series.) Of course, if you're doing this on a large scale, you could just have any kind of inverter made that handles whatever voltage you want. On the other hand, if you're using full packs you have the possibility of recycling motor controllers (also sometimes called inverters) from cars, which are designed to send 3-phase power to an AC motor, as a regular electrical system inverter running at fixed frequency. (Maybe fake the motor position sensor data so it always thinks the motor is spinning at a constant 3600 RPM, or 60HZ.) I don't know if modern motor controllers output a real sine wave or if they just output a square wave. I'm guessing it's probably the former, otherwise I'd expect you'd get a lot of extra noise and vibration. You could also re-use the car's original charger (the onboard part that converts 110V or 220V AC from a level1/level2 charger to DC at pack voltage). On the other hand, if the input power for charging is DC at the appropriate voltage to begin with, that part isn't needed.
- rektide 6y ago