4 ms·
"Almost everyone who has ever appeared in front of a court has claimed their rights were violated to the point where it's practically a meme. It's almost never
by giantg2 6y ago
"Almost everyone who has ever appeared in front of a court has claimed their rights were violated to the point where it's practically a meme. It's almost never the case."
A trooper knowingly held an incorrect charge, resulting in pretrial restrictions specific to that charge. It's a violation of of both the federal and state constitution to deprive anyone of liberty or property except by the law of the land, and there's nothing in the law allowing one to knowingly hold an incorrect charge. The ADA on the case had this information too and allowed the charge to continue - a violation of the Bar's professional standards. The trooper eventually amended the charge, but lied to the judge, saying it was out of leniency when I even have an IAD report saying it was because he had an incorrect charge and knew it. But they determined it was just a "misunderstanding". Even the rules of criminal procedure prohibits the amending of the charge at that point due to the circumstances.
"Misapplication of law is exactly what the appeals process is for."
That may be, but I think it's negligence to put an unknowlegable person in a position of power like that. States have laws about those practicing law needing to have a degree and pass the Bar, yet they don't care if a judge understands basic legal terminology. How dumb does one have to be to think that a request to dismiss with prejudice is the person calling you prejudiced? This system design flaw results in delays and costs to innocent people, not to mention undermining the integrity of the system. I'm my state the filing fee for an appeal is non-refundable, so you can be "fined" just to get a trial with a real judge even if you're innocent.
"What's more likely? 1. Every police officer, attorney, and court house, as well as every politician and all the media, doesn't care about widespread systemic violations of basic rights, documented wrongdoing, and misapplication of the law. 2. You're misinformed about the law."
Considering that an investigative journalist is pitching this story to their editor, that a civil rights lawyer says we have a case but the system doesn't view it favorably unless there's a lot of money involved, and that the statutes and case law supports my interpretation, then I'm leaning towards #1 (but your choices are flawed due to the use of absolutes. It should say that the system will protect the bad members as a means of protecting itself and because they don't want to deal with issues they see to be small).
"'even yell at you'
My goodness!"
That is a violation of judicial ethics and conduct...
"'There's zero accountability for the police, DA's office, and the courts.'
Simply not true."
This case seems to demonstrate a lack of accountability.