3 ms·
You cannot control for that. You can't give a control group a "placebo illness" such that they don't know whether it's Covid-19 or not (and make it double-blin
by kazinator 6y ago
You cannot control for that.
You can't give a control group a "placebo illness" such that they don't know whether it's Covid-19 or not (and make it double-blind so that the people administering this illness also don't know).
The people who overcame Covid-19 had an experience that members of a control group who did not overcome Covid-19 do not have.
That's an obvious source of bias, which is inherent to the study.
What would be credible would be data about people who had Covid-19 but did not know it (due to mild symptoms and no hospitalization), showing that those people have mental problems compared to a control group of those who didn't have Covid-19.
However, if there is a real physiological effect there, it
could be tied to the severity of the illness: i.e. how much damage it caused to the body. In that case, those secondary effects could be expected to be next to nonexistent in the mild group.
- loopz 6y agoYou can never really rely on just one study anyways. You then need metastudies and comparative studies where such flaws get weeded out or corrected for. So there will be significant lag in certainty, thus not suitable for much of decisionmaking now.
- necovek 6y agoThe effect might not even be physiological yet still be this prominent: having COVID-19 makes you doubly scared for your loved-ones, worry about your perception in the society (was I not careful enough?), worry about lingering side-effects, worry about missing extended time from work, etc. While this depends on the individual, you can notice effects of increased stress in large numbers. Your suggestion of another control group with Covid-19-but-no-symptoms would help answer that question too, though ideally we'd want those who had Covid19 but didn't know it at all. But anyway, this paper is only establishing correlation: getting to causation in medicine is the harder task and takes years or decades and even then it's usually inconclusive!