5 ms·
The author focuses the entire blog post on remote third party services that are alternatives to popular third party services financed by data collection as a "b
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
The author focuses the entire blog post on remote third party services that are alternatives to popular third party services financed by data collection as a "business model". IMO, the single most important component of a home network is not any piece of the hardware/software outside the home that the third parties may control, it is the internet gateway in the home. Routers were the most important computers at the dawn of the internet, and IMO they still are the most important computers today. If the internet gateway in the home is ignored as a point of control,^1 then IMO all bets are off.
A significant amount of data collection by third parties can be eliminated or reduced by retaining control over the internet gateway. Arguably this amount is even greater than what can be affected by simply switching to using carefully selected alternative third parties. IMO, it is a mistake to believe that one can reliably eliminate/reduce data collection simply by choosing the "right" third parties. Whack-A-Mole, cat-and-mouse, whatever the term we use, this is a game the user cannot win. Third parties providing "services" over the internet are outside the user's control. For worse not better, they are subjected to market forces that drive them to collect as much user data as they can get away with.
Regardless of these privacy-destructive market forces, it is still possible to build decent routers from BSD project source code and inexpensive hardware. IMO, this is time well spent.
1. Control by the user
- Daho0n 6y agoSadly many who want to control the gateway with something safe and open fall in the trap that is pfsense.
- reasonabl_human 6y agoWhat about it is a trap? Do you feel the same way about opnsense?
- Daho0n 6y agoNo, I'm in the process of moving to OPNsense. Unlike pfsense it's actually open source, not controlled by a company that tries to drive competition out with dirty tricks and they aren't trying to move their customers to a DRM solution.
- nullwarp 6y agoHow hard has it been to move to opnsense? I've been dragging my feet on doing it because my pfsense router is setup just where it needs to be but i really do want to move.
- antattack 6y agoOPNsense has recently upgraded to a new major version. To save aggravation, if you are not in a hurry, I would wait until minor version of 21.7.x https://opnsense.org/about/road-map/ https://opnsense.org/about/road-map/
- jrm4 6y agoOkay. How can we fix this? I'm dealing with it right now and this space is so hard -- likely somewhat deliberately so. I'm a 20+ year Linux user trying to get a single home network with multiple ISPs going and it just seems way harder than it ought to be; i.e. -- not that every bit of software needs to be idiot-proof, but this iptables/pfSense/netplan etc etc universe just feels downright hostile to the aspiring home user.
- hpcjoe 6y agoIt is. Multi-wan is easier with appliances. I used pfSense over the last 12 years or so with multi-wan on and off (currently off). I've run pfSense in a kvm VM, and you can do multi-wan with this. Though I generally recommend dedicated NICs for the WANs and LAN. I've looked at the linux based appliances (as late as last week) and only clearos or openwrt supported multi-wan. I could be wrong (I'd like to be as pfSense/OPNsense are FreeBSD based, and that comes with, sadly, huge amounts of baggage, limited hardware support, etc.). I'll likely be looking at that package as a potential replacement for the pfSense system, though if clearos can't handle what I need, OPNsense is like pfSense, but with far less baggage. If you don't mind tinkering, you might be able to use mwan3[1]. If you prefer OpenWRT, you can look at running it in a VM[2] along with mwan3. [1] https://github.com/Adze1502/mwan https://github.com/Adze1502/mwan [2] https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/virtualization/qemu https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/virtualization/qemu
- stock_toaster 6y agoI believe vyos supports WAN balancing (and/or failover).
- tesseract 6y agoI set up multi-WAN in a few small business contexts (on a Zyxel appliance, and on pfSense) and to be honest it was always a little flakier than I hoped. It was always failing over too quickly, or too slowly, or not reverting back to the primary WAN quickly enough when the failure/congestion cleared up. I think any sort of multi-WAN setup where you aren't actually an AS running BGP is doomed to be somewhat hacky. Of course running an AS is both a ton of work, and basically impossible for a residential customer anyway.
- nine_k 6y agoI wonder how much a gateway router can do here. Most of the data passing it are encrypted: https, SSH. Cutting off the phone-home requests is best done on respective devices: you can run firewalls on most desktops and laptops, and even phones. Рhones often go online via GSM or LTE, without passing through the home router. While a proxy like pihole can be helpful sometimes, cutting off tracking and ads is done best by browser extensions and by using open-source clients, where available. The best the home router should do is to not be vulnerable to exploits, and otherwise up-to-date, and fully under the owner's control That's why my home router runs openwrt.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"I wonder how much a gateway router can do here." "... cutting off tracking and ads is best done by browser extensions ..." What if the browser vendor, who is also a data collector, requires user to log in or otherwise identify herself before she can use extensions. A home "gateway" is a computer running a kernel with IP forwarding enabled that is being used as the point of egress from the home network to the internet. That is a broad definition and allows for much creativity. That is what I mean by the term "gateway". As such, a gateway can, both in theory and in practice, do anything/nothing that "desktops and laptops, and even phones" can do. Relying solely on pre-configured "limited/special purpose" OS projects as a replacement for DIY and creativity in setting up a gateway was not what I had in mind, but is certainly an option amongst many others.
- nine_k 6y agoDon't use such a browser then! Firefox is pretty good. An on-device firewall can firewall individual processes and applications. An upstream / gateway firewall does not have such fine-grained control. That was my point. Running stuff on my router is entirely possible, but I limit it to routing and running a wireguard endpoint. I prefer to run my private stuff in the confines of the home LAN.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Don't use such a browser then!" Never said that I did! :) I use a text-only browser for reading HTML. Many times I do even use a browser for making HTTP requests. Truly one can use all these strategies, application-based, router-based, gateway-based, if they are available. They are not mutually exclusive. Personally I just would not feel like I can rely on extensions or other solutions tied to some software I do not compile myself. (I do edit and compile the text-only browser.) All due respect to Firefox, but I have found compiling it is way too time and resource-intensive. It is way beyond what I need for recreational web use. Firefox users seem to rely on Mozilla to do the right things on their behalf. That is not the sort of "control by the user" I am after. What is behind Mozilla. Online advertising money. Cannot really count on them to do what I want.
- sergeykish 6y agoI am surprised too, it trully is home computer, connected to all computers inside and outside, and yet usual routers are cheap and dumb.
- slenk 6y agoYour definition makes routers sound pretty smart, not dumb? Cheap, yes.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoGateway, not router. I personally do very few and simple things on the gateway. Way less than what an average default-configured router running OpenWRT does.
- slenk 6y agoAh, yeah my bad.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoNo worries. Usually they are the same. The terms are probably interchangeable. The point I was trying to make is that the gateway does not necessarily have to be a pre-packaged router with a difficult-to-manage, complex configuration. It can be the computer over which the user feels she has the most control.
- sergeykish 6y agoSmart is Linux machine I use as router. It is uniquely suited to run services without interruption, like file share, messengers, torrent, http server, etc. Smartphone and laptops are mobile devices with spotty connection, powered by battery. Instead we've got Cloud.