7 ms·
Only 4.2 sigmas. ;) That is really a lot. It's less than the official arbitrary threshold of 5 sigmas to proclaim a discovery, but it's a lot. In the past, ex
by gus_massa 6y ago
Only 4.2 sigmas. ;)
That is really a lot. It's less than the official arbitrary threshold of 5 sigmas to proclaim a discovery, but it's a lot.
In the past, experiments with 2 or 3 sigmas were later classified as flukes, but AFAIK no experiment with 4 sigmas has "disappeared" later.
- comboy 6y agoNeutrinos faster than light had 6 sigma. It just shows probabilistic significance. Confirmation by independent research teams helps eliminate calculation and execution errors.
- thepangolino 6y agoThis is the second separate experiment giving similar value.
- XorNot 6y agoThe use of a secret frequency source not known to the experimenters is also a very good way to deal with potential bias.
- Robotbeat 6y agoThat does help a lot! Of course, this is still not good enough. But the nice thing about things that are real is they eventually stand up to increasing levels of self-doubt and 3rd party verification... it’s an extraordinary result (because, of course, the Standard Model seems to be sufficient for just about everything else... so any verified deviation is extraordinary), and so funding shouldn’t be a problem. A decent heuristic: Real effects are those that get bigger the more careful your experiment is (and the more times it is replicated by careful outsiders), not smaller.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- davrosthedalek 6y ago"Separate" for slightly small values of separate. It's the same measurement approach, and using many components from the first experiment, so there could be correlated errors. But they made many fundamental improvements to the experiment, so it's great to see that the effect hasn't gone away.
- ISL 6y agoThe primary shared component is the ring/yoke. I worked in the same lab as a substantial team of g-2 scientists for the last decade and watched them come to this result. The level of re-characterization of the properties of the entire instrument was extremely extensive. If anything, one should regard the lessons that they have learned along the way as providing extra insight into the properties of the original BNL measurement. To use a car analogy: This is as if you took someone's prize-winning race car, kept the moderately-priceless chassis, installed upgraded components in essentially every other sense (remove the piston engine, install a jet engine, remove the entire cockpit and replace with modern avionics, install entirely new outer shell, replace the tires with new materials that are two-decades newer...), put the car through the most extensive testing program anyone has ever performed on a race car, filled the gas tank with rocket fuel, and took it back to Le Mans. I believe that the likelihood of a meaningful ring-correlated systematic, while still possible, is quite low in this case. The magnetic-field mapping, shimming, and monitoring campaigns, in particular, should give people confidence that any run-to-run correlated impact of the ring ought to be very small.
- selectodude 6y agoIdeally they have all their fiber optic cables screwed on tight at Fermilab.
- gizmo686 6y agoAs I recall, FTL neutrinos were the result of experimental error, not chance; and so are outside the scope of what sigma screen for.
- theptip 6y agoIn scope for the context of this thread though; your GP claimed that 4 sigmas means “it’ll probably pan out as being real”, your parent provided a 6-sigma counter example.
- ianai 6y agoOr the title of this topic as it is right now is misleading. It says they’ve confirmed the stronger magnetic field. Ie it was either predicted elsewhere or seen elsewhere. The later would build confidence in the testing apparatus.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kbelder 6y ago"It's 99.99% significant, if we assume the 10% case that we haven't fucked up somewhere."
- a1369209993 6y ago> your GP claimed that 4 sigmas means "it'll probably pan out as being real" No they didn't; they claimed that 4 sigmas means it will probably turn out to be something other than statistical noise. They made no claims about "it's real" versus "it's a systematic, non-statistical error". See also https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/2440 https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/2440
- mhh__ 6y agoIt's probably worth saying that even "chance" is still a little misleading in the sense that the quantification of that chance is still done by the physicists and therefore can be biased
- 6y ago
- sgt101 6y agoOh sweet summer physicist, what do you know of reality? Reality is for the markets, lovely mathey person, when a one in a million chance comes every month, and investment portfolios lie scattered over the floor like the corpses on a battlefield. Reality is for when your mortgage and the kid's school fees are riding on it, and quantitative strategies are borne and die with the fads of last summers interns pet projects. In some domains 7 sigma events come and go - statistics is not something to be used to determine possibility in the absence of theory. If you go shopping you will buy a dress, just because it's a pretty one doesn't mean that it was made for you.