4 ms·
I'm not from the US, and so I only follow this from a distance, but: Taxes for the top 2 percent are very likely to go higher Is this actually true? Obama cou
by nl 15y ago
I'm not from the US, and so I only follow this from a distance, but:
Taxes for the top 2 percent are very likely to go higher
Is this actually true? Obama couldn't get support to rollback tax cuts on the rich - is he really going to be able to increase them now? I believe Republican policy is to cut taxes on the rich (?)
In the United States, the very rich hold most of that wealth in dollars, which are worth increasingly less.
This isn't true either is it? Firstly, don't most of the rich hold their wealth in investments (eg, shares), which might be denominated in US Dollars but are relatively immune to long term changes in value of the dollar? Secondly, (despite all the talk) actually hasn't been any significant inflation in the US. (I'll happily concede that the US dollar has deprecated against other currencies, but that shouldn't effect the domestic purchasing power of the rich that much - even allowing for outsized impact due to imported luxury goods)
- krohrbaugh 15y agoYeah; I almost stopped reading the article because the introductory paragraphs (which you are citing) were rubbish. Now is a great time to be rich in the US.
- cheez 15y agoNot to spoil your fun but it's always great to be rich.
- nl 15y agoit's always great to be rich. To be pedantic - the French and Russian (and many other) revolutions didn't work out great for the rich.
- WalterBright 15y agoThey didn't work out so well for the poor, either.
- atlantic 15y agoLet's not conflate the French and Russian revolutions - they have absolutely nothing in common. And yes, the French revolution did work out very well for the poor, eventually. It was at the root of the development of modern democracy in the Western world.
- nl 15y agoLet's not conflate the French and Russian revolutions - they have absolutely nothing in common. I have issues with the word "absolutely". They had quite a lot of common - both were about overthrowing a system of government based on birthright, and the participants in the Russian revolution certainly tried to learn from the French revolution. (One could argue that the Russian revolution was actually better for the poor in the short term than the French. Serfdom was immediately abolished, and it got them out of WW1. War had the biggest impact on the poor)
- philwelch 15y agoWell, there's the part where the monarchy collapses but no one really knows who's going to take over, and then there's the part where radicals take over, murder the entire royal family, and enforce a bloody reign of terror, and then there's the part where all the other countries in Europe get anxious about all the unrest and go to war with the revolting country, and then there's the part where the country ultimately ends up under an imperialist dictator who tries to conquer their neighbors. They were quite different affairs, yes, but it's an exaggeration to say they had absolutely nothing in common.
- arethuza 15y agoLenin came from a rather comfortable background - his father had been "elevated" into the nobility for his work in the government bureaucracy.
- nl 15y agoComfortable yes, rich no. Also, his brother was executed and the family was banished when Lenin was 17 (prior to him reading Marx).
- georgefox 15y agoIs this actually true? Obama couldn't get support to rollback tax cuts on the rich - is he really going to be able to increase them now? I believe Republican policy is to cut taxes on the rich (?) Spot on. The Bush tax cuts have only temporarily been extended, and the Democrats have expressed interest in eventually eliminating them for the top bracket only. I assume this is what the article is referring to. We'll see if that actually happens anytime soon. The Republicans certainly aren't going to support it because, as you said, their positions generally involve further cutting income taxes, if anything. Here's a chart that compares a recent Republican proposal to the Bush tax cuts: http://www.offthechartsblog.org/pawlenty%E2%80%99s-high-end-tax-cuts-dwarf-even-those-of-president-bush/ http://www.offthechartsblog.org/pawlenty%E2%80%99s-high-end-...