3 ms·
Imagine what it will take to go from space rock to underground chip factories. If we started today, it will take a thousand years or more to have a fully indepe
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Imagine what it will take to go from space rock to underground chip factories. If we started today, it will take a thousand years or more to have a fully independent Mars colony (one that could survive indefinitely if the Earth were hit by a gamma-ray burst, let's say).
The sheer population needed to run a complete supply chain for high-technology (on which Mars would be entirely dependent for basic life-support) is staggering. Having the entire thing built and operated underground would be an engineering and social feat of unprecedented scale in humanity's history.
Iamgining doing it in a generation is simply impossible. Its more likely to happen by quantum fluctuation in a second than by humanity's efforts in a generation with current technology.
- tim333 6y agoSingularity, robots... Not certain to happen but a fair bit more than your quantum fluctuation.
- _nalply 6y agoA gamma-ray burst killing Earth could also kill Mars. I don't know but perhaps the death ray could be as wide as several sun systems.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, my point was only the idea of a Mars colony surviving with 0 resources from Earth.
- _nalply 6y agoOf course I understand that, only the example with the gamma ray burst is not really useful here.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWell, one point I didn't make here but that made me pick that example is that, with the exception of a gamma ray burst, there is no tragedy that could realistically affect the Earth in such a way as to make it even CLOSE to how uninhabitable Mars is. Global warming, nuclear winter, asteroid hit, massive solar flare, supervolcano, plate tectonics - anything we care to imagine will leave the Earth much closer to being habitable than Mars.
- _nalply 6y agoA near supernova would also be extremely disastrous and also kill Mars. Perhaps global warming on Venus scale? Just playing along...
- Teever 6y ago> If we started today, it will take a thousand years or more to have a fully independent Mars colony But how do you know this? Are there any papers or reports that say that a thousand years is the lower bound on a self sustaining colony on another planet? It seems to me that this idea is a common wisdom that people often say because in their mind colonization is an out of reach idea so they just pick a random big sounding number like "a thousand years" as a placeholder for 'it is impossible" when there isn't any actual research that says it will take a thousand years.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, it's a made up number. But it's meant to give a sense of scale. Think about how economically unviable and hard it is to just create 1 new chip fab on Earth. And think about the fact that on Mars you would need to re-create the entire supply chain that already exists on Earth. Remember that the minerals that you need are probably about as spread-out on Mars as they are on Earth, so you will need a global network of mining stations and processing plants to get the various necessary metals - all this without any access to fossil fuels of any kind, and with all of humanity spending little time outside for fear of radiation. Perhaps establishing a colony that gets the vast majority of its supplies from Earth is doable in a generation or two (though of questionable value). But creating a self-sustaining colony is entirely out of reach for the forseeable future. You don't need actual research to tell you this any more than you need actual research to tell you that humans can't flap their wings to fly - a little bit of back-of-the-napkin calculations will quickly elucidate it.