9 ms·
Your phone number is a short unique identifier for you which follows you around for potentially your entire life, because the hassle of changing it is significa
by simonw 6y ago
Your phone number is a short unique identifier for you which follows you around for potentially your entire life, because the hassle of changing it is significant.
I imagine marketers find it significantly more valuable than an email address.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoIt's crazy how we have gone from the phone company publishing an entire index of everyone's names, addresses, and phone numbers, to ...this. what happened to the good old days of the white page phone books.
- billh 6y agoI'm not entirely convinced the good old days of the whitepages was actually good. The phone companies required you to purchase your privacy for a monthly fee if you didn't want to be included in their publications. Had these publications been privacy focused from the start and required opt-in instead of the extortion for privacy scheme; I have a feeling that these directories would not have existed in the form that they did, if at all.
- Bedon292 6y agoWe already know all possible phone numbers. I think the value would be in associating it with at least one more piece of data to correlate it with other data. At least tie it to some sort of demographics, but preferably an exact individual.
- MattGaiser 6y agoYeah, but simply knowing it isn’t all that useful. You need to control it.
- JimDabell 6y agoGuess what? I already have your phone number. So do the marketers. And we have everybody else’s in the world as well! Phone numbers are a small search space. You can just iterate through it to generate all possible phone numbers. Of course, I don’t know that your phone number belongs to you, but I have it. The same applies to this site if you enter your phone number in it. They will have your phone number… so what? They don’t know it’s your phone number, just that it‘s a phone number, which has zero value. If you search the web for your exact phone number, there’s a very good chance your phone number is on several “who called me?” websites already. How did they get your number? They didn’t. They just list every possible phone number and hope people will add comments saying who called them from that number. What information are you actually disclosing here, given that the number itself is worthless? That the phone number is associated with somebody who wants to know if it’s part of the Facebook breach? What value is that information / what are the risks associated with it? Scammers wouldn’t use it because anybody who is looking this information up is probably less likely than the average person to fall for a scam even when tailored to this breach. They’d probably get a better hit rate by excluding these numbers. How about associating it with whatever information your browser leaks / whatever tracking they can add? Use private browsing / incognito to reduce that. What value is knowing that a person with an arbitrary phone number uses Chrome vs Safari? What value is knowing that a person with a phone number from a certain area is browsing from an IP address also located in that area? All of the comments people have made about privacy here seem to be useless “oh my god, now they have your phone number!” panic that doesn’t seem to realise that a phone number in isolation is worthless. It’s possible that there are potential privacy problems here, but as far as I’ve seen, nobody has actually mentioned any.