3 ms·
> they have rug-pulled people with a hard fork. "People" here being criminals that exploited a flaw in the DAO, yeah?
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> they have rug-pulled people with a hard fork.
"People" here being criminals that exploited a flaw in the DAO, yeah?
- gruez 6y agoJust like how the US financial system only freezes the assets of Bad Guys, right? As for GME? We had to rugpull them because they were manipulating the market[1]. [1] Yes I know that wasn't the real reason why trading was halted
- whimsicalism 6y agoI don't know enough to comment on those things, I'm discussing the specific example of the ETH fork which was given.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y agoThe point is that in your initial comment, you were saying that with decentralized cryptocurrencies you'll be free from third party interference, but with ETH the DAO hacker was subject to the very interference you claimed crypto wasn't subject to. Therefore it weakens your claim from something like "with crypto, nobody can stop you!", to "with crypto, nobody can stop you! ...except if you do something we don't like in which case we'll hardfork", which is pretty similar to how centralized systems work today.
- whimsicalism 6y agoThat wasn't my comment. Also, people freely chose to start using the new version of ETH, they weren't required to.
- leppr 6y agoA hard fork in a decentralized cryptocurrency is democratic, users chose which of the 2 new chains assets' they want to keep. No binary winner is decided, the market currently values ETH as 122 times more valuable than ETC, but ETC is not censored. The sentencing of criminals in republics is very removed from democratic action (see drug criminalization).
- jude- 6y ago> A hard fork in a decentralized cryptocurrency is democratic, users chose which of the 2 new chains assets' they want to keep. Show us the votes, then. Did a majority of miners and/or coinholders vote to hard-fork?
- perryizgr8 6y ago> A hard fork in a decentralized cryptocurrency is democratic Yup, and I don't want public votes to decide the amount of money I have.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> public votes to decide the amount of money I have. Unfortunately, there is no alternative. The value of what you have is decided by what people are willing to pay for it in markets. If people decide that they value the forked ETH that doesn't provide the money to the people who stole from the DAO more than the version where those people have all of the money, then it is going to be more valuable. You don't escape this problem with fiat either. Basic market mechanisms like this are pretty much inescapable.
- leppr 6y agoGold or other physical scarce assets come pretty close to allowing you to escape this.
- whimsicalism 6y agoAh yes, the constant value of gold https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-year-chart https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-... As I said, there is no escaping market mechanisms, as value is market contextual. Certainly, there are assets with more or less stable value, but that is still due to the whims of what people (ie. the "public") are willing to pay.
- dogecoinbase 6y agoAt the time of that fork, the Ethereum website literally said "the code is the contract". Then, when someone found a perfectly legitimate use of that code that the creators failed to anticipate, they forcibly altered the contract. There are criminals here, but they're not the ones you think.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> they forcibly altered the contract. What was forcibly altered? Perhaps the meaning of "force" is different for you than it is for me.
- fastball 6y agoThe issue with this narrative is that the "they" isn't the creators, it's the network. The Ethereum core devs can do whatever they want, but if nodes don't migrate across the hard fork then nothing happens. The code is the contract, enforced by a decentralized network of actors. Of course that network can at any point change the contract if the majority of them agree to do so – how else would it work? The key is that there is no way for individual actors to modify contracts at will – you need consensus. It's the difference between oligarchy and democracy.
- dogecoinbase 6y agoIf the code is the contract, each of those actors is individually liable as a tortfeasor.