4 ms·
I reject the premise that architecting and programming are two separate fields.
by pavel_lishin 6y ago
I reject the premise that architecting and programming are two separate fields.
- oriolid 6y agoI thought he was writing about designing buildings for a moment.
- 01100011 6y agoMany people in our industry never get to do much architecting beyond a very limited scale. Much of my career was spent fixing bugs as a contractor or implementing very targeted features in embedded systems. It was only later on in my career where the balance shifted to more architecting of larger features. Plenty of folks are just 'programmers'. They're barely software 'engineers' and definitely not computer scientists. It is perfectly reasonable to spend your entire career as a programmer, dealing with small issues in a systems you inherited from someone else.
- edejong 6y agoI don't think the GP is claiming they are separate fields. However, I would say they are separate modes of thinking and require different skill sets. For example, software architecture around systems design might involve thinking of different layers of responsibility, the sequentiality of development, taking into account the skillsets of the teams and existing technical tools and structures. To me, programming is the art of transforming and ascertaining requirements and principles into executable structure. Architecture is the art of shaping the non-functional requirements and principles. Either by writing them down or by discussing them at a whiteboard, or even by teaching the team about these requirements. Both are like an entangled pair that can be incorporated in one single individual, in different team members or even in different organisational structures. Some architectural decisions can be championed by a random software developer. Some architectural decisions shape companies (AWS). And some architectures should just be thrown out of the window. But, and I am speaking from experience here, as they are different modes of thinking, there should be conscious time and effort for both and they should not be mixed indiscriminately.