6 ms·
Reaching the $5 Million Club Takes an Open Mind
- paraschopra 18y agoAnybody here read The Black Swan or Fooled by Randomness by Nasim Taleb? He so eloquently describes all the fallacies which this article is full of.
- tyn 18y agoCan you spot some?
- paraschopra 18y agoYep sure. For example, "3,000 pentamillionaires to discuss their path to success. Perhaps not surprisingly, none of them had a cushy union job down at the DMV. The vast majority — 80% — either started their own business or worked for a small company that saw explosive growth. And almost all of them made their fortune in a big lump sum after many years of effort." I'm sure Nasim would have laughed at this. Firstly, selecting a group of successful people and asking what made them successful makes u fall into a trap of believing that these factors led them to success and hence whoever adopts these factors will be as successful as them. Secondly, for each millionaire there would be many other normal people who did what the millionaire did but didn't see their bank account swelling. For a study to be insightful, the participants should have as many losers (if not more) as winners. Moreover, article confuses correlation with causality. The article is like: Google, Yahoo, Amazon, etc. have one thing in common: Silicon Valley hence being in Silicon Valley will get you to that status. Tell me how many startups actually become Google-like?
- byrneseyeview 18y agoAmazon is in Seattle.
- asdflkj 18y agoYour response does not address the passage you quoted. First of all, the author didn't ask them what made them successful. The quote has facts about their lives, not their thoughts on what made them successful. Second of all, the author doesn't claim that these traits are a sufficient condition for becoming rich; only that they'll help. And what the article says is closer to: "Google and Yahoo and most other successful internet companies have being in Silicon Valley in common, hence if you want to be a successful internet company, being in SV will help." Which is absolutely true.
- ericwan 18y agobut he's saying, in order to get rich very likely you will need to do those things other people dare not to do, i.e. doing these things raise your chance of getting rich, which is true.
- sdpurtill 18y agoSurprisingly, today's very rich say that money itself wasn't much of a motivator. Once you've got food in your belly and a big-screen TV, the mere prospect of more Benjamins isn't enough to get you leaping out of bed at 5 a.m. Rather, rich folks often make their fortunes after they make up their minds to solve a problem or do something better than it's been done before. Very true for me and I'm sure a lot of the HN community. Once you get past a certain point with money it becomes an after thought, then you have the freedom to think of other things (like big ideas) that will make you more money. The rich get richer for a reason...
- 13ren 18y agoParadoxically, the road to riches often means acting as if you already have that freedom. I think the only true freedom comes from within. Money can't give you this freedom; but this freedom can give you money.
- unalone 18y agoWhat's the Warren Buffet quote? The one where he said that he's not happy because he's made so much money, but he's made so much money because he's happy?
- ericwan 18y agoYep, especially for techies in america, they already have the right skills and conditions to feed themselves and families, then getting out of bed at 5am just to make some more sounds absurd. Not so much if your purpose is change the world, or be #1 in something.
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoYou remind me of Orson Scott Card's essay "How Software Companies Die": You can domesticate programmers the way beekeepers tame bees. You can't exactly communicate with them, but you can get them to swarm in one place and when they're not looking, you can carry off the honey. You keep these bees from stinging by paying them money. More money than they know what to do with. But that's less than you might think. You see, all these programmers keep hearing their parents' voices in their heads saying "When are you going to join the real world?" All you have to pay them is enough money that they can answer (also in their heads) "Geez, Dad, I'm making more than you." On average, this is cheap. This is not exactly in line with what we're talking about here - the founder type seems less likely to be satisfied in the described situation. But I think there is a parallel.
- smanek 18y agoThis was somewhat surprising to me: "The vast majority — 80% — either started their own business or worked for a small company that saw explosive growth. And almost all of them made their fortune in a big lump sum after many years of effort." I guess it just reaffirms the pg/yc philosophy.
- noonespecial 18y agoIt also decimates the "rich get richer", "us vs them" lines of BS politicians maniacally shovel our way in order to extract our votes. Good news folks. Its possible to get rich through hard work and a little cleverness. That's also the bad news.
- Retric 18y ago5M is a good retirement but it's not rich. When your assets are passively generating 5M a year then your rich.
- Retric 18y agoWith a good investment stratagy you can live off of ~4% of your capital per year and keep up with inflation. 4% of 5M is 200k/year. But if your retiring early you should aim for a 50% cushion which works out to 133k/year which far from amazing when you need to pay for your own heathcare etc. PS: Rich means "Possessing great material wealth" which I think it stands for more than just the ability to support an upper middle class lifestyle without working.
- stcredzero 18y agoBy the standards of most of the world, "comfortably middle class" in the US is rich.
- arockwell 18y agoI always defined "rich" as being independently wealthy, and 5M is plenty to achieve that.
- helveticaman 18y ago"Not to say that getting rich is simply a matter of having a swell attitude. The path to riches usually involves the kind of risk that would make most people feel a little queasy. Harrison Group head Jim Taylor recently persuaded more than 3,000 pentamillionaires to discuss their path to success. Perhaps not surprisingly, none of them had a cushy union job down at the DMV. The vast majority — 80% — either started their own business or worked for a small company that saw explosive growth. And almost all of them made their fortune in a big lump sum after many years of effort." The article mentions the other 20% is made up of heirs (10%) and fortunes from passive income / stock picking. The other 80% made it from startups. Of course, this leaves out the career ladder; don't MBAs get rich too? I don't envy them, but I know they exist, and I know they have money, as do MDs and JDs. Where do they fit in? Also: "Getting rich also requires a certain amount of stubbornness and clarity of purpose. Consultant Joel Kurtzman, who evaluated 350 startups for his book Startups That Work, found that successful outlets usually have a team of two or three founders who share a common vision; the success rate for this model was a remarkable 50%. The odds for solo founders were more like the oft-quoted one in 10, in part because they often found themselves working at cross-purposes with hired guns who see things differently. That's what 34-year-old Justin Jarvinen learned the hard way. The entrepreneur saw two promising business ventures go down the tubes after he took on partners who tweaked his ideas beyond recognition. But three years ago he started VerveLife, a service that helps companies promote online marketing efforts with free music downloads. Knowing that his success depended on his enthusiasm for bringing the idea to market, he carefully chose partners who supported his vision." So, according to this article: 80% of people who get rich do so w/ a startup 50% of good teams succeed 10% of solo founders succeed
- BrandonM 18y agoI would say that in general, for an MBA to reach the $5M point, they have to be part of a startup. For an MD to reach that point, he has to start a very successful practice or make some good investments to go along with his income. So I think those two positions already fit into the mentioned data.
- jedc 18y ago
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- baxter001 18y agoI started to doubt the wisdom of the article when I read: "To enter the nation's top 1%, you need more than $5 million." I know 'more than' isn't the same as 'greater than or equal to' but doesn't this indicate 1 in 100 Americans are multimillionaires?
- reitzensteinm 18y agoIt then goes on to say that there are 930,000 of them.
- gojomo 18y agoThe article is pretty sloppy with numbers and definitions. There's no indication their survey of 3000 is representative of all pentamillionaires, for example. But, there were about 106 million 'households' in the US in the 2000 census. Perhaps there are 110-115 million households today. If 930,000 of those households have a net worth over $5 million, that's very roughly in the 1% range. Wikipedia's article on {Millionaire} suggests about 9 million households have a million-dollar net worth, so 930,000 at the 5-million level seems plausible. So it's not that 1-in-100 Americans are pentamillionaires as individuals, but almost 1-in-100 live in a pentamillionaire household.
- menloparkbum 18y agoI don't think that the 80% extends past this guy's sample group of 3000. In fact if you do some "fermi calculations" it doesn't appear to be the case that 80% of pentamillionaires in America come from startups. The article claims there are 930,000 pentamillionaires in the united states. 80% of that is 744,000. There are about 1.1 million lawyers in the USA. Let's say the top 10% have a net worth of 5 million. Thus 110,000 of those pentamillionaires are lawyers. So we've got 634,000 left. There are about 700,000 doctors in the USA. 15% of those doctors are surgeons and anesthetists, specialties where you can make $500K/yr. So, 105,000 pentamillionaire doctors... 529,000 pentamillionaires left. 750 MLB players + 460 NBA Players + 1700 NFL players = 2910. Let's multiply that by the past 10 years = 29,000 current or former pro sports players who are pentamillionaires 500,000 pentamillionaires left I'm getting a bit tired to do this math, but it seems like there must be 100,000 guys in the financial sector who have a net worth of 5 million dollars. So - 400,000 left. Add in movie and TV stars, rock and pop music stars, guys who manage movie/TV/rock/pop stars, executives in the entertainment industry, the handful of other sport stars and entertainers who make a lot of money... that's probably another 100K. Down to 300,000. Now think about all the guys who rose up the ranks of fortune 500 companies. There's probably 100 guys at each fortune 500 company who make a mil a year? Now we're down to 250,000. Someone please correct me if I'm padding the numbers too much. I could be dead wrong on the number of rich finance sector guys, or totally wrong about how much money the top lawyers and doctors save. But, I also totally left out other rich people, like presidents of universities, university coaches, directors of rich nonprofit organizations, and so forth. Even if my math is off it really doesn't seem likely that 80% of the pentamillionaires in the USA came from startups. It seems closer to 10-20%, if that. Not trying to be a debbie downer but 80% seems way off the mark.
- 13ren 18y agoI don't know about your numbers, except that income does not necessarily imply assets... IIRC, from the survey done for "The Millionaire Mind" (<5, but anyway), many people had a family/lifestyle business. Technically, a start-up, but the corner fish n chip shop is probably not the first image evoked by the term. Another significant factor was frugality. A theory: the enforced savings of a startup is a significant factor in the retention of the created wealth.
- mick_m 18y ago> ... Takes an Open Mind ... or massive inflation.
- sdurkin 18y ago(930,000 / 300,000,000) != 1% This guy has his own special brand of math.