14 ms·
Happy that the ACLU is taking this on. It shouldn't matter, but if you look at the filed complaint[1] Ahmad is a US citizen. This treatment seems clearly uncon
by tyingq 6y ago
Happy that the ACLU is taking this on. It shouldn't matter, but if you look at the filed complaint[1] Ahmad is a US citizen. This treatment seems clearly unconstitutional to me.
Also, this excerpt from the complaint:
>In response, the agents pulled out two newspaper articles about Hezbollah and told Mr. Chebli, “We know you are a Hezbollah agent and were sent here by Hezbollah.”
What a couple of assholes.
[1] https://www.aclu.org/legal-document/chebli-v-kable-complaint-0 https://www.aclu.org/legal-document/chebli-v-kable-complaint...
- 3np 6y agoWhile it's terrible enough in either case, it does make a big difference that he's a citizen. Countries have another level of responsibility towards their citizens than to their residents. It shows in how AFAIK no country has even talked about restricting inbound travel for their citizens during the pandemic while even permanent residents have been blanket denied.
- goodcanadian 6y agoAustralia has severely rate limited the number of incoming passengers, including citizens. One year on, there are still tens of thousands of Australians unable to get home that want to do so.
- justaguy88 6y agoI haven't seen my parents in over a year due to this, it makes me pretty angry
- dx034 6y agoBut those are travel restrictions, not restrictions of entry. For Australia it doesn't make a big difference but they still cannot turn away citizens at their borders. They can detain people or quarantine them but not send them back. I'm not sure if there's any country where denying entry to your citizens is legal.
- 3np 6y agoJudging by the information here: https://covid19.homeaffairs.gov.au/travel-restrictions https://covid19.homeaffairs.gov.au/travel-restrictions It seems that citizens (and even permanent residents, which was not the case in e.g. Japan for several months) are free to enter. Sure, number of planes and seats are limited, but that's a different matter from denying entry at the border.
- goodcanadian 6y agoThat's like saying you can take as many cookies as you want when the plate is empty. There are citizens and residents who have been unable to get home for over a year!
- Taniwha 6y agoNZ allows both citizens and permanent residents to return home - however we have limited space in managed quarantine that limits how many can return at a time - and if you're just coming home for a holiday, not permanently, or you left for a holiday or biz trip, they will charge you for the whole process
- slguy48 6y agoSri Lanka banned all inbound passenger flights with only 24 hour notice stranding citizens abroad
- 3np 6y agoThey denied the flights, they did not deny their citizens entry - a different distinction, even if the immediate effect for an individual plays out similarly.
- grecy 6y agoIt's illegal for any country to deny entry to a citizen of said country. They can of course arrest you the second you set foot in the country, but that's an entirely different story. They must allow you to inter.
- bigiain 6y ago"Illegal" under what jurisdiction? > They must allow you to inter. That's evidently not true. Or at least grossly misleading. Countries can and are refusing to allow all people who want to get onto flights bound for the country they're citizens of. My country (.au) is currently limiting inbound international travellers to 3000 per week, with over 40,000 Australian citizens registered as trying to get home. Some of those people have been trying for close to 12 months to get home. These restrictions mean that airline seat pricing is going insane. In pre Covid times, I'd regularly fly Sydney to SF round trip for $AUD1500-$2000 or so on United. A recent news report says they're now flying business/first class only flights with the cheapest one way LA-SYD tickets being $AUD21,000. Can you imagine being on a trip last Jan/Feb with a return ticket for March or April, only to be told your return ticket keeps getting bumped for higher paying customers but you could always upgrade to a $21,000 ticket to get home. And your travel insurance says "Sucks to be you, you're not covered for pandemics, as outlined in section 374 on page 93 of your Product Disclosure Document you got when you paid your premium. Have a nice day!" So now you're stuck in the US, originally of a 90 day tourist visa waiver and not legally able to work, and there's no casual work available anyway because of Covid shutdowns, and you've needed to manage to find food/shelter for 12 months while waiting for a flight home. I know one of those people, and know of several more...
- 3np 6y agoThere is an important distinction here - they're restricting the number of inbound planes, as opposed to barring their citizens from entry. Theoretically speaking, if a ship crew of only AU citizens would dock at an Australian port, they would not be denied entry given that they follow quarantine procedures, I assume?
- mod 6y agoDo you mean that all 206-ish countries have laws on the books about this?
- elliekelly 6y agoThe complaint is absolutely disgusting to read. One (I suspect uncontested) fact alleged in the complaint really stood out to me: > As a result, he was stranded in Lebanon for over a month, during which time the U.S. government confirmed that he had been placed on the No Fly List. Mr. Chebli was then able to obtain a one-time waiver to fly home. If someone is dangerous enough to be on the No Fly List why would the US government allow them to fly? To the US? Even once? And if they're safe enough to fly on that occasion why are they, upon landing (presumably safely), once again considered unsafe to fly? The No Fly List logic just doesn't quite add up for me...
- nashashmi 6y agoHow many other people are stuck in this way abroad?
- tyingq 6y agoIt's not a terrific workaround, but I suppose you could fly into Canada or Mexico and then ground transport across the border.
- giantg2 6y agoOr a boat. I think there might be an issue with these too. It's titled a no-fly list, but I think they have additional restrictions too. I'm not sure if they deny entry based on it too.
- at-fates-hands 6y agoThe first time the FBI went to interview him, he should have requested an attorney - whether he had one or not. As soon as you lawyer up (which is totally legal in his case) the FBI get really itchy about having to deal with lawyers and probably would've moved on to another target. He should have also gone to the media much sooner or threatened to take this public. Yes, it is now, but had he gone to the media sooner, I'm sure the FBI would've backed off a lot sooner. Having a Muslim racially profiled, intimidated and then put on a no-fly list for no reason is not a good look for that agency.
- cortesoft 6y ago> Having a Muslim racially profiled, intimidated and then put on a no-fly list for no reason is not a good look for that agency. We have had a steady stream of stories like this for almost 20 years now. Nothing substantial has changed. I don’t think the FBI is worried about PR around this at this point.
- tyingq 6y agoThis could be substantially different for them. The guy is a citizen, works for an "All American" type company (Ford), etc. And the ACLU picked up the case.
- giantg2 6y agoEven if they win, who will enforce it? The FBI/DOJ are supposed to be the ones investigating color of law and law enforcement misconduct.
- tyingq 6y agoThis seems interesting in that area. He can sue individual FBI agents for monetary damages: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/10/supreme-court-says-muslims-placed-on-no-fly-list-can-sue-fbi-agents.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/10/supreme-court-says-muslims-p...
- 6y ago
- JPKab 6y agoI'm glad the ACLU is taking this on, but if Ahmad was a Trump supporting redneck from West Virginia who refused to be an informant in an investigation of the January 6th riot, they wouldn't touch it. And that's a big problem, because the old ACLU didn't care how unpopular and disgusting the client was. They cared that abuse of power against the unpopular is an inevitable slippery slope towards abuse of power against all citizens.
- adamcstephens 6y agoI agree the ACLU lost its way, but disagree that the FBI would act like this with a redneck in WV.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>but disagree that the FBI would act like this with a redneck in WV. The only thing stopping them is that there's probably a few grey beards who remember the media hell they got for the Texas BBQ
- bsder 6y ago> They cared that abuse of power against the unpopular is an inevitable slippery slope towards abuse of power against all citizens. They also have to care about having a case that will win and not lose and set bad precedent. Unfortunately, the Supreme Court is stacked against them and they have to have cases that will provoke public outrage if it goes the wrong way to prevent the court from going too far off track. Having sympathetic defendants is unfortunately something required for right now. There is a reason why you know about Rosa Parks and not Claudette Colvin.
- mleonhard 6y agoHe is very lucky to be a US citizen. The FBI has treated non-citizens much much worse. For example [0], the FBI arrested Syrian-Canadian engineer Maher Arer while he changed planes in USA. The FBI imprisoned him without charges, denied him a lawyer, and then kidnapped him and delivered him to a prison in Syria where he was tortured for 10 months. His wife finally got the Canadian government to intervene and get him out. The head of RCMP (Canada's FBI) resigned in shame for letting it happen. All of the US people responsible continued with their lives as before. A few of them apologized. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar
- refurb 6y agoYou seem to glossing over Canada’s hand-in-hand role with the US in that situation.