5 ms·
Production for a datacenter CPU is not the same as production for datacenter + enthusiast-grade consumer CPUs like Zen 3 currently achieves, unfortunately. Rock
by judge2020 6y ago
Production for a datacenter CPU is not the same as production for datacenter + enthusiast-grade consumer CPUs like Zen 3 currently achieves, unfortunately. Rocket lake being backported to 14nm is still not a good sign for actual production volume, although it probably means next generation will be 10nm all the way.
- willis936 6y agoDatacenter CPUs are much larger than consumer parts and yield goes down with the square of the die area. They start with these because the margins go up faster than square of the die area.
- Robotbeat 6y agoBut modern techniques exist to deal with problems in a large die (ie testing and then segmenting off cores with mistakes on them), so the fact they’re starting with large chip die sizes doesn’t really tell you much, no?
- erik 6y agoThe top end most profitable SKUs are fully enabled dies. That they are now able to ship dies this large is a good sign. The 10nm laptop chips they have produced so far were rumored to have atrocious yield.
- JudasGoat 6y ago"The top end most profitable SKUs are fully enabled dies." If you take a part that would be discarded because it didn't make "top end" binning, and sell it as a lesser(core count or clock speed) chip. Isn't that profit from what would otherwise be scrap?
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoDie harvesting is not perfect. If there is an error in a logic transistor, they can turn off that cpu core and use the rest of the chip. If there is a short between ground and power, the whole chip is useless because it will melt when you plug it in. Yields on larger chips are still substantially worse than smaller chips, even with harvesting.
- Robotbeat 6y agoInteresting, that’s informative. Well that sounds like a big advantage for the chiplet approach.
- 29083011397778 6y agoAnd here I always thought it was because, should your large die have an issue, you can likely sell it as a lower-binned SKU with the failed area gated off. This way you end up with more inventory of a chip you intend to sell, or you have a high margin chip - win-win!
- bushbaba 6y agoI assume for intel, they make more server CPUs per year than the entirety of AMDs output.
- ryan_j_naughton 6y agoThere is a slow but seismic shift to AMD within data centers right now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mhh__ 6y agoThey still have something like 40% to go to even reach parity with Intel though
- aoeusnth1 6y agoIt’s harder to go from 0.1% to 10% than it is to go from 10% to 50%.
- bushbaba 6y agoYes and no. It’s harder to convince folks to switch going from 0.1% to 10%. But you are also talking about winning the low hanging fruits. once you get those easy wins the rest take a bit to chip away at. while initial growth was 100x, that pace is going to slow down as marketshare increases.
- csunbird 6y agoWhy not ARM? ARM is now penetrating the consumer development devices (M1), why not mirror that in the servers as well?
- dTal 6y agoBecause M1s are light years ahead of anything else, and you can't buy M1s outside of a Mac.
- totalZero 6y ago> Rocket lake being backported to 14nm is still not a good sign for actual production volume I'm genuinely having trouble understanding what you mean by this. Rocket Lake being backported to 14nm means that 10nm can be allocated in greater proportion toward higher-priced chips like Alder Lake and Ice Lake SP. Seems like it would be good for production volume.
- rincebrain 6y agoI think they mean that the fact that they needed to backport Rocket Lake, versus just having all their production on 10nm, implies a much more limited production capacity than the other situation.
- zamadatix 6y agoProduction volume referring to production volume of the node still being low as a whole not risks to the being able to get volume of these particular SKUs using the node.
- jlawer 6y agoI was under the impression the issue with 10nm is frequency, which lead to the rocket lake backport. Unfortunately it seems that the 10nm node's efficiency point is lower on the frequency curve. The reviewed ice lake processor was 300mhz lower then the previous generation (though with much higher core count), despite higher power draw and the process node shrink. In laptop processors they can easily show efficiency gains from the 10nm process and IPC improvement, It appears most laptop processors end up running a power envelope lower then the ideal performance per watt efficiency. Server Processors with higher core counts means you can run more workloads per server, again providing efficiency gains. However desktop / gaming tends to be smaller core count + higher frequency with little concern of efficiency outside of quality of life factors (i.e. don't make me use a 1KW chiller). Intel has been pushing 5ghz processor frequency for years, and rocket lake continues that push (5.3ghz boost), when they drop frequency to move to 10nm, its hard to see an IPC improvement that is able to paper over that. However alder lake CPUs will have a thread count advantage, so at least with 24 threads it should be able to show generational improvement over the current 8c/16 rocket lake parts. That will allow them to at least argue their value with select benchmarks and intel only features. Those 8 efficiency cores will likely be a BIG win on laptop, but on desktop I doubt they will compare favourably to the full fat cores on a current Ryzen 5900x (i.e. a currently available 24 core processor). Intel is going to have at least 1 more BAD mainstream desktop generation before they can truely compete on the mainstream high end, however there is a chance they have something like a HEDT part that would allow them to at least save face. That being said, given a choice, Intel will give up desktop market share for the faster growing laptop and server markets.
- knz_ 6y ago> Rocket lake being backported to 14nm is still not a good sign for actual production volume, I'm not seeing a good reason for thinking this is the case. Server CPUs are harder to fab (much larger die area) and they need to fab more of them (desktop CPUs are relatively niche compared to mobile and server CPUs). If anything this is a sign that 10nm is fully ready.