5 ms·
i must admit i'm somewhat impressed how fast the hackers and cheaters managed to take over bitcoin trading. i think it's kind of cute. people hoped for an econ
by skrebbel 15y ago
i must admit i'm somewhat impressed how fast the hackers and cheaters managed to take over bitcoin trading.
i think it's kind of cute. people hoped for an economy no government could control, and got exactly that: anarchy and a burning world.
- leon_ 15y agowell the IRL exchanges are run by cheaters and there's not much anarchy around yet.
- kiba 15y agoIt just mean that the market is really small.
- mikemoka 15y agodo you mean that if the market would be bigger such things won't be done? they could do more of the same unfortunately..
- Macha 15y agoIf the market was bigger, 500k would not crash it, as there would be enough buy orders to take someone dumping 500k. It would still be crashable, but more would be needed if it was bigger.
- seats 15y agoWhen the market is really big, then only the really rich people can manipulate it. Comforting thought ;)
- wmf 15y agoIt's already a little disturbing to realize that a single account held 261K BTC out of 6.5M BTC in circulation.
- seats 15y agoI wonder how the distribution of bitcoins compares to that of dollars
- Synaesthesia 15y agoI think that someone actually kept that 250k BTC in their MTGox account!
- saulrh 15y agoIf I'm doing my math right, $500k is something like 2% of the bitcoin economy. Imagine what would happen to wall street if someone cashed out a few trillion dollars' worth of stock at once.
- swishercutter 15y agoand honestly it only dropped for a minute...then it went right back over $14...so even if this had really been legit it would have sorta recovered.
- jerf 15y agoAnd if "your math" is "number of BitCoins extant time current market value of one BitCoin", your math is not correct. Macha is correct; crashing the market with $500K is proof that the entire MtGox exchange can't be much larger than that, no matter what multiplication says.
- saulrh 15y agoOf course MtGox isn't much bigger than $500k per ten minutes. Given how many bitcoins there are and how much each is worth, that kind of volume would be like every cent in the United States changing hands every couple of hours.
- jerf 15y agoYou have a terribly flawed idea of how exchanges work and what they are; your logic doesn't flow at all. But I can't really correct that in an HN post.
- saulrh 15y agoEntirely possible; I'm writing these before bed after getting home from work. I just have a feeling that if someone tried to convert 2% of the world's USD to rubles in a few seconds without an equivalent transfer in the opposite direction everything would explode. MtGox not being able to handle a transaction like this simply means that there was less than 500k flowing in the opposite direction every ten minutes. If there were, that would imply either a spectacular amount of arbitrage or enough transactions going on inside bitcoin for people to be changing 500k back and forth every ten minutes. This crash just means that neither of those are happening, which I find entirely believable.
- plamenv 15y agoYes, the mayhem at the beginning is expected but I'm curious if the trial/error process could actually bring some sound stable system at the end. I'm inclined to think that this won't happen because most of the people in the bitcoin "economy" have some serious dislike for central authorities. And it's hard to design a stable monetary system without some kind of regulation and more transparency.
- wnight 15y agoWanting to avoid single points of failure doesn't seem that strange to me. It's an engineering decision, not a political one. Central authority is just a central system to hack, or become corrupt. You wouldn't let your business become reliant on a single-supplier part, why would you let it rely on a single-supplier currency? Regulations are only worth as much as the authority regulating them, if that. Just look at the USA. All the laws required to stop the recent mortgage meltdown were already in place and could still be used, but won't be. What value do those unused regulations have? It's better to have less fake regulations and simply not depend on a non-existent safety net.
- vrotaru 15y ago> the hackers and cheaters To throw in a bit of conspiracy theory, it may have been the good guys... P.S. If the latest news are to be trusted it was a cheater. Actually the $1000 he got, is a rather low price to pay for a lesson that... instructive.
- mcantelon 15y agoSounds like it has been dealt with pretty well: https://support.mtgox.com/entries/20208066-huge-bitcoin-sell-off-due-to-a-compromised-account-rollback https://support.mtgox.com/entries/20208066-huge-bitcoin-sell...
- gst 15y agoWhere is anarchy? What's burning? Someone sold a huge amount of Bitcoins. The market acted accordingly. Expect a bounce back to the old exchange rate as soon as Mt. Gox is available again. Of course it might be possible that the computer of the person who sold the Bitcoin was cracked. But that's not the fault of Bitcoin - if someone is not capable of taking care of the security of his local computer, it's better not to use a distributed currency where your money is basically stored inside a single file.
- skrebbel 15y ago> Of course it might be possible that the computer of the person who sold the Bitcoin was cracked. But that's not the fault of Bitcoin. Just like it's not the fault of the dollar if someone mugs you at gunpoint. Except robbing someone typically requires you to take physical risks and (threaten to) use violence. I'll be very curious to see any effective way of tracking down bitcoin thieves. If you have to be a security expert to own more than a few dollars worth of bitcoins, the project has effectively failed already.
- weavejester 15y agoIf you have to be a security expert to own more than a few dollars worth of bitcoins, the project has effectively failed already. Why? It's true that key management and security are not as good as they could be in the official client, but that doesn't mean the project has failed, merely that the client needs to be improved.
- wladimir 15y agoImproving the wallet security is priority #1 of the dev team at the moment. Note that no one of the developers expected it to get this big this fast. Six months ago, no one would even bother stealing bitcoins as they were not more than a toy curiousity. Now very serious amounts of money are represented.
- gst 15y agoYou don't necessarily have to be a security expert to use Bitcoins, just if you want to run the client by yourself. If you don't have the required knowledge just pay a little bit to a "Bitcoin bank" that handles the task for you. In the real world you also don't carry your money with you all the time, but store it on a bank.
- econgeeker 15y agoYou're right about the anarchy, but I don't see the burning world. I don't see hackers and cheaters "taking over" bitcoin. An account was compromised, and despite there being no government regulation, the exchange stepped in, protected their customer, rolled back the trades and protected the market. That is anarchy exactly! But no burning world. And it is yet another realworld test that has been successfully met by the bitcoin idea. I'm not sold on bitcoins viability, due to questions about the larger marketability and having not done an audit of the software. But from an economic perspective, bitcoin is a viable currency, or as close to meeting all the requirements that any non-physical currency can.
- danielsoneg 15y ago> and despite there being no government regulation, the exchange stepped in, protected their customer, rolled back the trades and protected the market You know that's basically the same thing - central entity with overarching authority exerts its will over the market, canceling transactions it's deemed 'fraudulent' between two independent consenting entities. "Free hand of the market" ain't present here, chief - this is regulation.
- wmf 15y agoI would argue that it's not the same thing, since people use Mt.Gox voluntarily. We can expect no-rollback exchanges to appear any day now.
- danielsoneg 15y agoDo they? It's by far the largest BTC exchange - by a factor of ~50 or so. If you want to exchange more than a couple hundred BTC, they're the only game in town right now.
- ryepdx 15y agoYes, but they're the only big game in town not because they held a gun to anyone's head or threatened to throw their customers in jail if they dared to start using another exchange, but because they provided the best service. They did not engage in coercion. This is the heart of the free market and of anarchy.
- smokeyj 15y agoDid you not read the outcome? The accounts are being rolled back while other exchanges are operating fine. These kinks have to be worked out and it's better late than never - even though it's relatively early.