3 ms·
YouTube Claims Less Than 0.2% of Total Views Are of Videos That Violate Policies
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe notion that views or presentations of material is a useful (and quite arguably the most appropriate) metric for abuse, and most especially contrasted with items posted, first surfaced that I'm aware from Facebook's VP Integrity, Guy Rosen, as "prevalence", in an 11 Dec 2020 tweet: https://nitter.cc/guyro/status/1337493574246535168?s=20 https://nitter.cc/guyro/status/1337493574246535168?s=20 Rosen's tweet disclosed a content-violation prevalence of 0.10--0.11% of views, and falling as of 11 February to 0.07--0.08%, 7-8 views per 10,000 on the platform. There are several other articles addressing YouTube's new "violative view rate" metric. Variety had the best mix of clear headline and minimal paywall, but other substantive coverage is at: "Tracking Viral Misinformation" (NYTimes): https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/2020-election-misinformation-distortions/youtube-discloses-the-percentage-of-views-going-to-videos-that-break-its-rules https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/2020-election-misinformati... "YouTube says it’s better at removing videos that violate its rules, but those rules are in flux" (recode/Vox): https://www.vox.com/recode/2021/4/6/22368809/youtube-violative-view-rate-content-moderation-guidelines-spam-hate-speech https://www.vox.com/recode/2021/4/6/22368809/youtube-violati... "YouTube claims it’s getting better at enforcing its own moderation rules" (The Verge): https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/6/22368505/youtube-violative-view-rate-transparency-stat https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/6/22368505/youtube-violative... Whether you call it "prevalence", "views", or "violative view rate", the notion that you want to look at some function of items of content times reception of that content seems apt. Severity or risk metrics for both content and audience may also be useful --- this is starting to sound an awful lot like an advertising campaign, but one for which the aim is to mimimise impacts based on the material, exposures, and receiving audience. Such a measure also, at least partially, side-steps some concerns over free speech, and resembles in part characteristics of other public-carriage / public-service functions, in which general access is permitted, but harmful or violative access remains constrained, regulated, and specifically discouraged. The notion that an entity might publish to a platform, but see limited prevalence (say, exposure to only direct or close followers), that identified clusters which are known to amplify disinformation have their capability to do so curtailed, or the like, address at least one line of current concerns with social media's socially-corrosive disruptive capabilities. (The fact that one person's terrorist is often another's freedom fighter remains, and is not easily resolved. But at least the overall problem is now reduced in size.)
- sharemywin 6y agoit's still a cesspool of crap. with some decent beginner tech tutorials on there from time to time.
- dredmorbius 6y agoSturgeon's Law and all. Search, intent, and aggressive pruning of the crap-surfacing mechanisms (most especially recommended videos, comments on all but the very best channels) are your friends. The console-mode mps-youtube utility was for a brief, shining moment the best possible interface into the abyss, as it allowed: - Direct search - Viewing all of a specific channel's videos, or searching within them. - Compiling offline, savable, file-based playlists. It doesn't, AFAIK, permit blocklisting/whitelisting of specific channels, though that would be glorious. I'd made extensive use of this for a time, ultimately however the API was limited out and the tool is now effectively unusable. mpv and VLC however continue to rock hard. Cal Newport has a few browser extension recommendations which purge recommendations. You can achieve much the same result with uMatrix's "block element" feature, or CSS editors/managers such as Stylus. (Do NOT use "Stylish", which is now adware/malware.)