4 ms·
Maybe the density is the same, but the 10-nm process variant that Intel is forced to use for Ice Lake Server is much worse than the 7-nm TSMC process. It is wo
by adrian_b 6y ago
Maybe the density is the same, but the 10-nm process variant that Intel is forced to use for Ice Lake Server is much worse than the 7-nm TSMC process.
It is worse in the sense that at the same number of active cores and the same power consumption, the 10-nm Ice Lake Server can reach only a much lower clock frequency than the 7-nm Epyc, which results in a much lower performance for anything that does not use AVX-512.
It is also worse in the sense that the maximum clock frequency when the power limits are not reached is also much worse for the 10-nm process used for Ice Lake Server.
Ice Lake Server does not use the improved 10-nm process (SuperFin) that is used for Tiger Lake and it is strongly handicapped because of that.
- ac29 6y agoWhile I'd agree with you that TSMC's current 7nm seems to be better than Intel's current 10nm, comparing Epyc to Ice Lake SP isnt quite the same. Intel is putting (up to) 40 cores on the same die, AMD only puts 8 cores. It looks like AMD has the better method for overall performance, and Intel will likely follow them - in addition to being able to get more cores into a socket, I suspect Intel could also crank frequency higher with less cores per die.
- adrian_b 6y agoFor the user it does not matter how many cores are on a die. For the user it matters what is included in a package. The new Ice Lake Server package (77.5 mm x 56.5 mm) has finally reached about the same size as the Epyc package (75.4 mm x 58.5 mm), because now Intel offers for the first time 8 memory channels, like its competitors have offered for many years. So in packages of the same size, Intel has 40 cores, while AMD offers 64 cores. Moreover Intel requires an extra package for the I/O controller, while AMD includes it in the CPU package. So for general-purpose users, AMD offers much more in the same space. On the other hand, Ice Lake Server has twice the number of FMA units, so it has as many floating-point multipliers as 80 AMD cores. This advantage is diminished by the fact that the clock frequency for heavy AVX-512 instructions is only 80% of the nominal frequency, but it can still give an advantage to Ice Lake Server for the programs that can use AVX-512.
- totalZero 6y agoFrom a yield perspective, if core failures are independent events, binning is probably easier with the big chiplet approach. The Epyc 3 approach does have some drawbacks. Looking at the Epyc 3 TDP numbers, there's probably a nontrivial thermal cost to breaking out the dies as AMD has. Not to mention the I/O for Epyc 3 is not on TSMC 7nm.