3 ms·
Studies keep saying this. People keep pointing to these studies, and demanding policy changes. But I've yet to see a study that makes any claims about: 1. What
by vkou 6y ago
Studies keep saying this. People keep pointing to these studies, and demanding policy changes. But I've yet to see a study that makes any claims about:
1. What percentage of these people can catch COVID.
2. How likely they are to infect someone else if they do.
For some reason, communities around the world keep getting second, third, fourth, and fifth waves of infections, and viral variants keep evolving, despite the proliferations of studies like this.
It's like measuring the level of humidity at ground level, and using that to conclude that it's raining. Yes, there's a correlation. No, that's not a reliable way to measure rainfall. A reliable way to measure rainfall is putting a bucket out.
- maxerickson 6y agoThis study is about antibodies stemming from infection with other viruses and explicitly does not come to a conclusion about whether they are meaningfully protective against SARS-CoV2.
- vkou 6y agoI'm well aware of this. That's what makes it useless for making policy decisions, just like my ground-level hygrometer is useless for telling me if its raining... But my bucket isn't. The fact that communities open up -> communities get another wave of COVID keeps playing out over and over again leads me to believe that neither #1 or #2 are likely to be favourable to us.