2 ms·
Based on your posts, I never would have guessed that you wanted to eliminate the rentier class, since everything you propose does little to eliminate their acti
by epistasis 6y ago
Based on your posts, I never would have guessed that you wanted to eliminate the rentier class, since everything you propose does little to eliminate their activity, and seems dedicated to maintaining their main source of profits: increased asset values.
In supply-constrained markets, asset appreciation far outpaces the revenue from rents. So if you charge taxes on vacant apartments, the asset owner may try harder to rent out the unit, but that just increases their profits even more.
When profits from asset appreciation eclipse rent revenues, establishing rent caps does little to eliminate rentier profits. Already, loans are predicated on rents not increasing above inflation, so rent caps do nothing to curb asset appreciation, especially as long as rental units can also be owned (for example single unit detached homes).
Limiting the number of properties that somebody can own does little to force "small landlordism," unless you also ban the ownership of property by LLCs or other organizations, which would also ban many better forms of ownership like co-ops.
The core problem is not the profits, even though that is problematic. Rentier profits just a symptom of the real problem: asset price appreciation due to exclusionary practices. That's what must be attacked head on, with socialization of land use so that when lots of people want to live in an area, they are allowed to, and anti democratic landowners are not allowed to exclude new people. Ironically, the pure landlords are less often against such proposals, it's the rentier homeowners that are often the ones who subvert society and in turn force profits to landlords. Though quite often, these exclusionary homeowners have become "small" landlords too, and doubly invested in keeping our new people to maximize their unearned profits.