3 ms·
>$200K after taxes is not that much, especially if you have a house, more than one car, children, student loan debt, want to save, etc. I understand your point
by bumby 6y ago
>$200K after taxes is not that much, especially if you have a house, more than one car, children, student loan debt, want to save, etc.
I understand your point, particularly if you are referencing a high COL area like SV. But this reads as a bit tone deaf when the median salary in the US is a shade under $40k/yr [1]
[1] https://usafacts.org/data/topics/economy/jobs-and-income/jobs-and-wages/median-annual-wage/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=ND-Jobs&gclid=CjwKCAjwjbCDBhAwEiwAiudBy7Nx6TrHdDScb4UZpeqnWaxN6jus5W6EvlBkF4CpzoYUSZCnvEhToxoC518QAvD_BwE https://usafacts.org/data/topics/economy/jobs-and-income/job...
- burlesona 6y agoHonestly I think a global or national percentile is not very informative. If you make $40k in a small town, you’re doing okay. If you make $80k in a mid-major city like Indianapolis or Raleigh, you’re doing okay. If you make $160k in San Francisco you’re doing okay. From my own life experience, all of those feel like about the same amount of purchasing power after you’ve paid your bills. However if you’re making $40k in SF your housing situation is borderline desperate. At $80k you’re just scraping by. The US has really fractured into a few different economies, and it’s as hard to make comparisons of income, wealth, and quality of life between San Francisco and rural Kansas as it is to make comparisons between the rural US and rural Guatemala (or any number of other countries).
- bumby 6y agoI agree 100%. That’s why I don’t think statements like “$X amount is really not that much” are very useful. In many places in the US $200k is doing really, really well. Sometimes those arguments are still used in those areas, but I think it says more about lifestyle inflation than the ability to live on that income. (E.g., it’s not much IF you get a new car every few years and IF you have a mortgage on a 4K Sqft home and IF you send your kids to private school). The tone deaf comment relates to how those self-imposed lifestyle constraints are out of touch for most people anyway.
- beardedetim 6y agoI don’t see an issue with saying both that $200k is not that much and that the median salary in the US is ABSOLUTELY TOO LOW. Both can be true and not tone deaf. Do you disagree? Or put another way: why did you find the comment tone deaf?
- bumby 6y agoIt can potentially be true but probably only to a certain extent. I find it tone deaf because the vast majority of people are getting by on much, much less. Which means almost by definition, it IS quite a bit. So to say it isn’t much comes across as oblivious to the way most people live, and potentially not aware of the problems that the average person faces. Would you complain to a person in a wheelchair about how bad it sucks to have to take the stairs to work even though it may still be true? Giving the OP the benefit of the doubt, it may be COL dependent. But even in SV, $200k is nearly double the median household income and nearly 4x the median personal income. It reminds me of an article I read during the financial crises of 2007-2009 written by someone who was making the case that being a one-percenter doesn’t mean you have lots of money. She then later described her new Lexus payment, costs of private school, oversized mortgage etc. Both can be true iff that is considered a reasonable lifestyle for the average person. To be generous to the OP, the average way an American lives is probably not the best measuring stick (e.g., something like 60+% can’t meet an unexpected $500 bill. However, just like the OPs statement, I tend to think this is related more to lifestyle choices)
- beardedetim 6y agoThat makes total sense. I disagree with your takeaway but it seems like a valid one to have. From my experience coming from homelessness type of poverty to making 6 figures, I have access to many things and don’t have to worry about food anymore. But. I still don’t have enough savings to live off of if I lose my job, am still one serious accident away from bankruptcy, etc. the way I’ve explained it is that I now have something to lose, not that I’ve gained all that much outside of benefits (I now have two front teeth!) Maybe the point I’m trying to make with my anecdote is that making $$$ isn’t the same as having $$$, high CoL or not.