3 ms·
I wouldn't say that phrase is actually anti-science. Science is fundamentally a social institution where groups of people can great bodies of knowledge that ca
by Symmetry 15y ago
I wouldn't say that phrase is actually anti-science.
Science is fundamentally a social institution where groups of people can great bodies of knowledge that can be used to make accurate predictions about the world. This body of knowledge is imperfect and so periodically people challenge it, making predictions where they hope their theories will be right and the standard model will be wrong. The thing is, there are many more ways to be wrong than to be right, and the large majority of people trying to challenge established knowledge are wrong.
Because of this we generally ought to use commonly accepted views until people challenging them can point to ways that their theories can make predictions that are superior to accepted theories. New theories might be intuitivly appealing, but if they can't pull their empirical weight they shouldn't get anywhere.
In fact, my reading of George Robinson's theory is that it would predict that the US economy would be much more unstable after going off the gold standard, when in fact it tended to be more unstable before we did. Now, if his book actually did predict "fewer but worse" recessions maybe we should look into it, but I'm worried that it doesn't.