5 ms·
> it’s more dangerous than ever (while I lived here) I agree that QoL in NYC is awful, but it's not "more dangerous than ever". Like in every other US city, th
by smt88 6y ago
> it’s more dangerous than ever (while I lived here)
I agree that QoL in NYC is awful, but it's not "more dangerous than ever". Like in every other US city, the crime rate is near an all-time low[1]. Murders spiked during Covid, but they're still low compared to previous decades.
> Add to that the “you’re not paying you’re fair share attitude” which I’m definitely getting
Where do you get this attitude? I have never experienced that in the city.
In fact, it's one of the places where the rich seem to be the least scrutinized, because most of them pay lip service to liberal values while still being 100,000x richer than a middle-class person living a few neighborhoods away.
1. https://www.factcheck.org/2020/07/giulianis-misleading-attack-on-de-blasio-and-crime/ https://www.factcheck.org/2020/07/giulianis-misleading-attac...
- negzero7 6y agoI'd be interested to see the crime stats from the last year to today - from the sentiment I've seen on social media it appears violence has been increasing since the Jul 2 your source article was posted. Add to that they slashed the police budget on Jul 1[1] I think the OP may have a valid point. -------- [1] - https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/01/us/new-york-budget-nypd-1-billion-cut-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/01/us/new-york-budget-nypd-1-bil...
- pc86 6y ago10 months of increases does not negate two decades of decreases. And that's even assuming there is an increase, since "the sentiment on social media" may very well be incorrect as is the comment purporting a more dangerous NYC.
- lefstathiou 6y agoRe crime, the parenthetical in my OP was my sloppy attempt to clarify it’s the most dangerous it’s been while I have lived here (18 years). Re where I get the attitude, our mayor and local representatives (like AOC) have both said this. There’ve been numerous marches down 6th Ave and the West Side Highway as well.
- smt88 6y ago> it’s the most dangerous it’s been while I have lived here (18 years) It's not, though. Do you have any data to back it up? All cause mortality has been very steady (with the exception of Sept 11 and Covid)[1]. Murders are near an all-time low[2] and are at nearly half of what they were when you moved to NYC. Felonies are lower, muggings are lower, everything is lower. So what does "dangerous" mean to you and where can we see something to back up the idea that the entire city is more dangerous? 1. https://twitter.com/joe_pickrell/status/1248721149233713153/photo/1 https://twitter.com/joe_pickrell/status/1248721149233713153/... 2. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0c/NYC_murders2.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0c/NYC_murd...
- JohnTHaller 6y agoFox News and their siblings (NY Post, WSJ mainly editorial, etc) have been running with the NYC is over narrative for quite a while. Especially the 'more dangerous than ever' trope. And they always talk about moving to TX and FL where the large cities have a homicide rate 2 to 4x what NYC's is.
- smt88 6y agoI honestly think the main culprit is local news. They're essentially non-journalists, so they basically cover violent crimes as sensationally as possible.
- JohnTHaller 6y agoI have relatives in red states who ask me how I can live somewhere as dangerous as NYC. Meanwhile, they're living in a metro area with triple the homicide rate of NYC.
- dagw 6y agoLike in every other US city, the crime rate is near an all-time low[1]. Murders spiked during Covid, but they're still low compared to previous decades. Those statistics focus on murder and 'major' crimes, and it's great that they are down. However as a city dweller the crimes that I actually worry about and the thing that makes a city feel "dangerous" are 'minor' crimes like pick pockets, muggings, vandalism and 'minor' assaults.
- smt88 6y ago> the crimes that I actually worry about and the thing that makes a city feel "dangerous" are 'minor' crimes like pick pockets, muggings, vandalism and 'minor' assaults Those are also down[1] in NYC, as they are across the country. If you can find any statistics that show otherwise, please share the link. 1. https://www.cityrating.com/crime-statistics/new-york/new-york.html https://www.cityrating.com/crime-statistics/new-york/new-yor...
- tarboreus 6y agoThe stats are useless. The police need them to go down, so they go down. My partner and a friend came on a woman who was getting mugged and the guy ran off with her bag. They called 911 and the cops showed up, didn't get out of the car, blew cigarette smoke in their faces, and said, "You don't want to report this, do you?" My partner had to walk her home since they just drove away. If you do insist on reporting, they make you pay for it, you could be at the station for 5 hours, which happened to my mother after her car was broken into by a homeless man. They're encouraged to not report specific kinds of crimes.
- smt88 6y ago> The stats are useless. The police need them to go down, so they go down. How do you know there is more manipulation of the stats now than there was at any other point in the past? If you're saying the official stats can't be trusted, you're just saying that no one knows how bad crime is. Or maybe you're saying no one knows except you? Regardless, you can't argue that crime is going up based on anecdotes, regardless of whether the official stats are trustworthy or not. > If you do insist on reporting, they make you pay for it, you could be at the station for 5 hours, which happened to my mother after her car was broken into by a homeless man. They're encouraged to not report specific kinds of crimes. So you're saying that's true in every city in the US? There's no city that's trying to do honest crime reporting? Because this isn't just a trend in NYC.