2 ms·
For asset ownership, where ownership involves massive down payments, this seems like a backwards approach. Where are all these first time buyers going to get th
by epistasis 6y ago
For asset ownership, where ownership involves massive down payments, this seems like a backwards approach. Where are all these first time buyers going to get their down payment? Put yourself in the shoes of somebody who is not already wealthy enough to own a home and see that continual rise in property value, amplified by the 5x leverage of a loan. It's impossible. Taxing landlords may mean for fewer landlords buying, but unless all those young people can somehow buy, it does nothing to solve the problem.
> YIMBYs' squawking
The huge advantage of the "squawking" which you are unfairly biased against is that it eliminates the profits that these speculators are depending upon.
The rise in prices is 100% dependent on a shortage of housing. If there wasn't a shortage, the market would correct. It may take a year or two of surplus housing to flush out those who are holding on for higher prices and teach them the new reality that they can't depend upon massive unearned gains every year, but it is the only way.
The other advantage of building surplus housing is that it gives people what they want. It stops the hoarding of a few wealthy people and opens up a desirable place to more people. This is nearly as big a benefit as lower prices.
Band aids on far downstream symptoms are not going to solve anything. And people are far too happy to only look at the symptoms rather than the underlying cause.
- pydry 6y ago>Where are all these first time buyers going to get their down payment? With a collapse in house prices, this problem is self solving.
- epistasis 6y agoIn places like Vancouver and the SF Bay Area, this is no longer true. The down payment amounts are often a multiple of annual household income, and even a drop by 30% will not solve much.