2 ms·
Take this for what it's worth, but virtually every example I see here is for applications that are supported on Linux, but certainly not specifically targeted t
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Take this for what it's worth, but virtually every example I see here is for applications that are supported on Linux, but certainly not specifically targeted towards Linux. Looking through the comments I see Jetbrains apps (which are built in Java and designed to be cross-platform), Steam, Sublime, Spotify, Dropbox, etc. I can guarantee all of those apps make the vast majority of their money from paying Mac and Windows customers, and they either offer a Linux version because they can afford to for essentially developer goodwill, or there is an interoperability story (e.g. a Dropbox user may use Mac most of the time, but needs it to manage some shared storage on all of their machines, including some Linux ones). Perhaps one exception I could see to this is highly technical or engineering focused software (e.g. Matlab, CAD software), but that software is largely paid for by large organizations like companies and universities.
HN folks may not like to hear it, but in general your "average" Linux user makes the absolute worst software customer: they can get tons of stuff for free so there is a high bar when it comes to willingness to pay for non-free software, they have very high demands about how software should work, and they are most likely to run customer configurations on different combinations of hardware, making bugs more likely, and they are usually quickest to switch if something better comes along.
And by the way, calling someone a "bad customer" is not really a putdown; being highly discerning about where one spends their money is more of a compliment.
- 3np 6y agoI absolutely think that there’s currently an untapped market for paid software where as part of the deal you get the source code (obv preferable libre but could do shared source) I can’t be the only one who got to the point where I simply won’t trust closed source binaries on my devices if I can avoid it, and would happily pay just to be able to verify that there’s no shenanigans going on. Realized this as I tried finding an email client for iOS - save from the stock one there’s just nothing out there where I have any idea what’s actually happening to my data. There is no norm or culture for business model, payment structure or payment mechanisms for this right now - am I alone or are we a larger untapped market waiting to be captured?
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThere is still a lot of piracy of paid software, offering the source code is only going to make that worse.
- huhtenberg 6y agoThat's without considering a very real risk of repackaging and rip-offs, especially when these are paired with aggressive SEO. This alone makes releasing the source of a commercial software a remarkably shortsighted move.
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoI'm on Linux, and I pay for software. I have a PulsSMS, a PyCharm a Sublime licence, and a recurring sub for Dynalist. There is no way I would have paid for those software if they would have not been linux compatible. But on the other end, I understand how right you are: we are very bad customers. I would not myself write a software and sell it only for Linux users. In fact, I would probably do the opposite: write a software that is paid for Windows and Mac users, but free for linux users. The later won't bring much money anyway, so it's already almost pro bono work, but you need the interrop story if you want to lure devs in.
- sangnoir 6y ago> HN folks may not like to hear it, but in general your "average" Linux user makes the absolute worst software customer: they can get tons of stuff for free so there is a high bar when it comes to willingness to pay for non-free software, they have very high demands about how software should work, and they are most likely to run customer configurations on different combinations of hardware, making bugs more likely, and they are usually quickest to switch if something better comes along. My charitable interpretation is that the average (voluntary) Linux user is a Pro user - but the average Mac/Windows users are consumers. What this means to the author is they probably shouldn't attempt selling consumer-type applications on Linux (which you noted have plenty of competing free apps). The additional challenge is that application distribution on Linux is seamless - your competition is one "apt get" command away, unlike Windows/Mac OS. Author - you probably have to write specialized/pro software to get reasonable traction on Linux targeted at a specific niche. It may be difficult to achieve this as a solo developer, as it will demand a lot of your time to get the required depth; but you can always start small.
- huhtenberg 6y ago> they probably shouldn't attempt selling consumer-type applications on Linux That's pretty damn insightful actually. Spot on.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI mean, being a Pro user is part of it, but it's not the only story. Pro designers are famously fans of Mac's, and they are certainly willing to pay a ton for lots of different types of software. I think part of it is just cultural. Linux got it's start after all as a free (in both senses of the word) alternative to costly commercial products. I mean, just look at Git, which was created after some original kernel devs (not just Linus BTW) wanted to reverse engineer/clone BitKeeper.
- sangnoir 6y ago> Pro designers are famously fans of Mac's, and they are certainly willing to pay a ton for lots of different types of software. That is true, and to compound to what you said earlier, Pro users are demanding and finicky, as Apple found out when it released Final Cut "Pro" X - which should have been Final Cut Prosumer. Apple lost years worth of goodwill overnight, because of shifting demographics of Apple users and Apple's own failure to balance the needs of casual, prosumers and actual video professionals. The same thing will happen to Pro designers, should Apple lose focus on attention to color accuracy and screen quality. The trouble with Linux is that it's hard to build tools for people with strong opinions, who can build their own, better, free versions of the tools when sufficiently motivated - your Git example will suffice.