4 ms·
> an arsonist that just burns down buildings for the lawls Yeah there aren't many people like that and the people who are like that don't belong in a prison.
by stormbrew 6y ago
> an arsonist that just burns down buildings for the lawls
Yeah there aren't many people like that and the people who are like that don't belong in a prison.
Anyways, one of the best ways to make someone "a continued drain on society due to continued criminal activity" is to put them in prison, give them a career-killing record that will follow them forever, and put them in contact with other criminals on a daily basis.
Prison is a self-reinforcing system that is itself the drain on society.
- umvi 6y ago> Yeah there aren't many people like that and the people who are like that don't belong in a prison. So where do they belong? If you say "mental hospital", what's to stop them from simply leaving? If the answer is anything other than "nothing" how is said mental hospital any different from a prison? I guess the question is, if not prison, what do you do with the people that prove time and again to be incompatible with society?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PopeRigby 6y agoWhat should ideally be happening would be rehabilitating them in an environment that doesn't constantly reinforce the idea that they're subhuman garbage.
- Pfhreak 6y agoInvoluntary in-patient psych care is different than prison because it is focused on improving someone's life, managing a potentially dangerous condition, etc. They (should be) a hopeful place, a place of healing. They don't always live up to that, of course, but at least the objectives are correct. Prisons are not places of rehabilitation in the US, and a person who is suffering from a severe mental illness is likely to suffer profound abuse in prison.
- ryandrake 6y agoInvoluntary psychiatric facilities also have a rather checkered past when it comes to human rights, to put it mildly. Anywhere you hold someone against their will eventually becomes fraught, no matter what the stated purpose of the facility is.
- Pfhreak 6y agoTrue, though I'd much rather have a well funded, competently run mental health facility than a well funded, competently run prison.
- stormbrew 6y agoThere's an extremely wide gamut of potential answers to this question. "Either we lock them up and throw away the key in a violent retributive system or we let them roam the streets free of all social constraint" is a false dilemma. At any rate, it's not necessary to pick a specific answer from the massive pile of alternative approaches tried, theorized, and developed in modern history to say that this one thing that is done in the US right now is clearly not the right answer.