3 ms·
No. "Assume it's copyrightable. It's still fair use." That means you don't have to answer "Is it copyrightable?" The Supreme Court generally prefers to not
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
No. "Assume it's copyrightable. It's still fair use." That means you don't have to answer "Is it copyrightable?" The Supreme Court generally prefers to not answer questions that they don't have to answer.
- shemnon42 6y agoSo in programmer speak if (!isFairUse(workUnderInvestigation) && copyrightable(originalWork)) { bigCopyrightPayout(); } Short circuit on the and operator. It's fair use, so copyrightable will not be evaluated. Evaluating copyrightable has an obervable side effect of creating a precedent.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYes, exactly that. Why do the && in that order? Because isFairUse(workUnderInvestigation) was a much less expensive operation than copyrightable(originalWork) for this particular value of originalWork.
- shemnon42 6y agoThat is the order scotus considered it.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoRight, and that's why SCOTUS considered it in that order. Deciding API copyright was a much bigger decision than deciding fair use.
- sjwright 6y agoA shame, because as test cases go that wouldn’t have been a terrible one.