2 ms·
> This suggests to me that someone who copies a set of function declarations for the purposes of, say, creating a free-software clone of an existing product mig
by bitwize 6y ago
> This suggests to me that someone who copies a set of function declarations for the purposes of, say, creating a free-software clone of an existing product might not be able to rely on this decision.
They wouldn't need to rely on this decision.
The courts tend to frown on using IP law as a weapon against interoperability or legitimate competition outside the scope of what the IP law covers. If you get sued for copying Yoyodyne's API in order to develop an otherwise original piece of software whose purpose is to interact with other software that expects Yoyodyne's program, the appeals court is likely to smack the suit down citing Sega v. Accolade and Sony v. Connectix, and the SCOTUS (assuming it gets that far) is likely to agree.
One of Oracle's major arguments was that Android was not interoperable with regular Java, and in Oracle's position the fact that Google copied Java's declaring code just to screw Oracle over put Android outside the bounds of interoperability fair-use protection.