4 ms·
>If you look at some of the sites in that report listed as having contaminated water, many are located near military bases, like Oceanside CA. These bases are t
by hammock 6y ago
>If you look at some of the sites in that report listed as having contaminated water, many are located near military bases, like Oceanside CA. These bases are the largest sources of ground water contamination of all sorts but specifically PFAS because they routinely practice fire suppression exercises.
I read a report recently that suggested the DoD was scrambling to incinerate its firefighting foam supplies, to avoid a PR disaster. However, the safety of incineration as disposal method has been called into serious question, namely that it doesn't sufficiently break it down and instead distributes it more widely through the environment. Any insight from you or your partner?
- cptskippy 6y agoAccording to my partner, the purpose of incineration is to break down the sulfur bonds rendering the resultant chemicals inert. However one of the attractive characteristics of PFAs is it's stability, so breaking these bonds requires a tremendous amount of energy. No particular insight into the DoD's disposal but it's entirely possible, and wouldn't be surprising, to find that the DoD is carrying out the destruction improperly.
- nate_meurer 6y ago> so breaking these bonds requires a tremendous amount of energy. Nope. C-F bonds are chemically very stable, but they exhibit high thermal reactivity and degrade far below proper incineration temperatures. Proper incineration, where the flu gasses are maintained at over 800 deg C, will easily drive all flourinated organics to their mineral endpoint, which is HF. And none of this has anything to do with the sulfur. For one thing, most end-use PFA products don't contain any sulfur. PTFE, for example, has no sulfur in it, yet many of its thermal degradation products are quite toxic. Sulfur is only present in chemicals used as surfactants, such as the water repellent coatings and fire retardants. But there is no evidence that merely cleaving the sulfonate group would make the compounds harmless.
- petertodd 6y agoGood example re: thermal reactivity is how teflon coated pans can kill birds if you let them overheat, eg by letting a pan boil dry: http://www.animalplanet.com/pets/other-pets/teflon-bird-guide/ http://www.animalplanet.com/pets/other-pets/teflon-bird-guid... Causes harm to humans too. But birds happen to be particularly susceptible. Looks like the research agrees with you re: incineration: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0045653519306435 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004565351... "Results indicate that, within procedural quantitation limits, no statistically significant evidence was found that the PFAS studied were created during the incineration of PTFE. Therefore, municipal incineration of PTFE using best available technologies (BAT) is not a significant source of the studied PFAS and should be considered an acceptable form of waste treatment."
- jhayward 6y agoI don't know which form of incineration is being used but for very harmful substances it is usually pyrolysis within a sealed container rather than being burned in open atmosphere. So the results of whatever the process may be are not released but can be disposed of in whatever way their new chemistry dictates.