15 ms·
The real problem here is Uber/Lyft not accounting for this in their app. As someone who takes rideshare with a small child who needs a car seat, I've had simil
by jedberg 6y ago
The real problem here is Uber/Lyft not accounting for this in their app. As someone who takes rideshare with a small child who needs a car seat, I've had similar issues.
A person with a dog will need extra time getting in and out, and the driver will need extra time to clean the car and remove any dog hair or other stains or spots. A person with a carseat like myself needs extra time to get into and out of the car while I strap in the carseat. I'm really good at it, but it still takes an extra minute or so to strap in the seat and then strap the child into the seat.
The apps need a way for me to say "I have a carseat" or "I have a service animal" and then give a bonus to the driver for picking me up. Incentivize the driver to want to come get me, and compensate them for the extra time. I'd gladly pay and extra "carseat fee" so that I don't get an unhappy driver who gives me one star just because they had to wait for me.
And in the case of the service animal, they shouldn't have the option to reject the ride and the rider should not get charged extra, but Uber/Lyft should have to compensate the driver for taking that ride as a cost the rideshare companies bear under the ADA.
- paulcole 6y ago> The real problem here is Uber/Lyft not accounting for this in their app No. The real problem is that a person with a disability was denied service in violation of the ADA. There's no setting in the app that prevents a driver from saying (as they should), "Get in."
- spuz 6y agoExactly. As the article says: > In 2014, The National Federation of the Blind in the US sued the ride-sharing app over guide-dog regulations. > The case was settled in 2017 when Uber agreed to ensure its drivers knew they were legally obliged to provide service to people with guide dogs. So Uber have clearly failed to train their drivers to treat disabled passengers in the right way. There are definitely lots of problems that could be solved with a better UI but this isn't one of them.
- sorokod 6y agoThe way you phrase it makes it sound like a UI issue. It is probably more accurate to say that Uber chooses to not provide this sort of functionality.
- jedberg 6y agoI mean, I'd call it a UX issue, where the U here is both the driver and the passenger. There is no way for me to tell the driver I have a car seat, and there is no way for the driver to get extra compensation for it. Now that they've added tipping I can at least tip them extra, but they don't know that until after they give me a bad rating for "wasting their time".
- snapetom 6y agoOp is saying implementing that is a minor inconvenience for Uber. If they wanted you to be able to tell the driver, it would take them a couple of weeks.
- sorokod 6y agoYup
- jedberg 6y agoI'd say OP is wrong. The Uber UX is localized into many languages. It probably takes them quite an effort to make any UI change, especially ones that require localization. Also, the change I'm proposing changes the fee structure as well. I'm sure they do deep analysis any time they change the fee structure. It would probably take a ton of effort to add what I suggest. I think they should do it, but it probably doesn't come up often enough to be worth it.
- zachrip 6y agoNot every feature is launched everywhere. If they want to test out a new feature they probably pick a single market and try it out there I'd bet. > I think they should do it, but it probably doesn't come up often enough to be worth it. That's the thing, it's not worth it to the people that are not affected by these situations. To those that are, it's life changing. Which is part of the reason ADA appears to side so heavily with those with disabilities. A tiny inconvenience to a driver means a blind person can make it to work on time. The driver should of course be compensated for their time and any cleanup required should also be covered - that's a no brainer. Totally understand the fear of dogs or allergies, but people systematically abuse those situations which further reduces ease of access for those with real disabilities. Emotional support animals on planes for example - plenty of people need them but a lot of others just used it to get their animal on the plane.
- Causality1 6y agoWhy shouldn't they have the option to reject the ride? What if they're allergic, or deathly afraid of dogs? I have a friend like that. Anything bigger than a chihuahua and she'd probably flee the vehicle before driving it anywhere. Being able to reject work you can't handle seems like the one silver lining of being "independent contractors".
- jedberg 6y agoThen they shouldn't be in the rideshare business. Or any job that requires direct contact with customers. If you work in retail you don't have the choice to avoid someone with a service dog either. It's just easier to ask your coworker to take over for you.
- slig 6y agoMost people in the "rideshare business" are working there because they don't have a better alternative.
- jedberg 6y agoI mean, I sympathize with them, but that's no excuse. If you can't stand blood you don't become a janitor at a hospital. If you can't stand raw meat you don't become a janitor at butcher shop. There are other ways to drive a car for money that don't involve interacting with people and their possible service animals.
- mcguire 6y agoIf they are physically unable to work in the "rideshare business", however....
- Pfhreak 6y agoBecause service animals are protected under the ADA. If folks could unilaterally reject working around service animals, we'd put the folks most at need at a significant detriment. If you work in a customer facing capacity, you should be prepared to encounter service animals, full stop.
- valuearb 6y agoIt's not the service animals that are the problem, is the "emotional support" animals, or more specifically, their owners.
- akiselev 6y agoWhich is a problem for legislators. Taxi drivers should not be the arbiters of whether an animal is a true support animal or not.
- adoxyz 6y ago100% agree. "emotional support" animals are basically a free pass for shitty people to take advantage of the system and take their non-trained, horribly mannered animals with them wherever they want, which sucks for people that have actual need for emotional support and service animals.
- arenaninja 6y agoI was out for breakfast for the first time since the pandemic started this weekend (I'm fully vaccinated now) and in walks a guy with a dog sporting a "Service Animal" sash that in tiny letters said "emotional support". I was paralyzed - I was traumatized by my interactions with dogs when I was a kid; where's my say in having untrained animals in my vicinity? This kind of shit needs to be ended but there should be NO issue with blind people with actual service animals receiving service anywhere
- jschwartzi 6y agoYeah my brother's wife will completely shut down and start screaming if a dog comes within 5 feet of her. Where she grew up in China dogs were wild animals that would viciously attack you if you got near them, so it's a pretty understandable reaction. So I'm not sure why you're getting downvoted here. Also having personally seen how poorly trained most peoples' dogs are I would be very uncomfortable having a random stranger's dog near me. A lot of the dogs I encounter on the street are neurotic wrecks incapable of passing without barking, leash pulling, or lunging.
- kube-system 6y agoI don't think Uber/Lyft wants to take the responsibility of ADA compliance, because that is implying that their drivers are employees.
- CPLX 6y agoRight. And I don’t want to continue to engage in the ludicrous bad faith argument that I’m not hiring Uber when I used the app to hire an Uber.
- dnautics 6y agoTaxis don't have their drivers as employees, and that sort of dispatch mechanism is exactly how they handle it.
- kube-system 6y agoThere's also a lot of taxi companies who are being sued for misclassification, so I don't really think their actions hold much value as a model for legal compliance.
- reaperducer 6y agoUber is at least aware of its responsibilities. When I drove for Uber, we received email messages every couple of months reminding us of the rules concerning service animals and people who need physical assistance getting in and out of the car. I seem to recall that if you had the right kind of car you could mark yourself available for wheelchairs and other things. I was forever picking up people with walkers and helping them in and out, though I know some drivers never ever wanted to touch a passenger unless they were dead drunk and had to be dragged out of the car and deposited on the front lawn of the destination address. (Been there, done that.) Maybe it's regional. Everything about Uber seems to be.
- subsaharancoder 6y ago> I seem to recall that if you had the right kind of car you could mark yourself available for wheelchairs and other things. I was forever picking up people with walkers and helping them in and out, though I know some drivers never ever wanted to touch a passenger unless they were dead drunk and had to be dragged out of the car and deposited on the front lawn of the destination address. (Been there, done that.) Uber had/has WAV (Wheelchair Accessible Vehicles) on request.
- lhorie 6y agoFWIW, Uber does offer an option called UberAssist[0], which is available in San Francisco (where this woman is from). And as someone else pointed out, Uber sends emails to drivers periodically. What more can it do? Boot drivers after a discrimination incident? By then, it's already too late. [0] https://www.uber.com/blog/los-angeles/introducing-uberassist-la/ https://www.uber.com/blog/los-angeles/introducing-uberassist...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yarcob 6y agoI think you are giving service providers way too much leeway. Service providers should offer their service to everyone, not just to "easy" customers. Service providers should not reject you because you are disabled, because you have a child, because you have a certain religion, or whatever else is the problem. If someone is in the business of transporting people, they shouldn't be allowed to just pick the most profitable customers. Because if you allow that, everyone will try to undercut the competitors prices to get the "good" customers, and nobody will bother to offer services to the not so profitable customers. There's nothing wrong with needing some special accomodations, and you shouldn't have to apologise to the driver for taking two minutes to fasten a child seat.
- usbline 6y agoThis is someone's personal property we're talking about. Should they forced to shuttle around drunken and incontinent people too? Why should anyone be coerced with being kicked off of a platform and losing (their possibly only) source of income because they don't want piss, shit, and vomit in their car?
- yarcob 6y agoGood point. Please note that I wrote: "There's nothing wrong with needing some special accomodations". I did not say you need to accomodate everything. If someone is drunk enough that he's going to piss and throw up in the car, it might be a better idea to call an ambulance instead. But to be honest, if you are in the transportation business, someone is going to fuck up your car sooner or later, and you really need to take potential cleaning costs into account. That's just part of the job. Don't want your car to get dirty from driving people? Then don't offer to drive people.
- amyjess 6y agoBecause the Americans With Disabilities Act tells them they have to.
- usbline 6y ago
- OJFord 6y ago> The apps need a way for me to say "I have a carseat" or "I have a service animal" In the UK (and EU?) those are 'protected characteristics' that it'd be illegal to discriminate against. I suppose you could ask 'for information purposes', but you'd have to be prepared to defend yourself, proving that it didn't affect the service received. > and then give a bonus to the driver for picking me up. Like that. Of course people are free to think 'this driver was an unusually nice guy to me and went above and beyond to help with my wheelchair', or whatever, but it absolutely couldn't be required of the customer. You can't have a 'parent or guide dog user' surcharge.
- Rule35 6y agoThis attitude that everything is the service providers problem is why service for the disabled is shitty. It does take longer to get into a car, etc, and that does cost a hungry driver more money. The extra cost should be born by society, which is where the requirement comes from. If we think the disabled should ride for the same price we should make that part of medical coverage and pay the driver for the extra time spent. As is, any sensible driver will ditch these fares with any means possible. More work, less money, and generally bitchier customers. The next time your fare comes up they'll pull over and take a bathroom break rather than responding. If we want something, we have to pay for it, not try to stick someone else with the bill.
- OJFord 6y ago> This attitude [...] is why service for the disabled is shitty. Is 'this attitude' mine (GP's)? As far as I'm aware I simply described the legal reality. The point is that the driver may not 'ditch these fares', and that Uber (et al.) simply bares any difference as the cost of doing business. They are not allowed, by law, to discriminate between a disabled passenger who 'takes too long', an able-bodied speedy passenger, and an able-bodied passenger who 'takes too long' for unforeseeable reasons, so it is just what it is (the 'forseeable' as the 'unforseeable').
- Rule35 6y agoIt's society's attitude. That we can fix a problem by making it someone else's problem. In the end it costs all of us more because we're still stuck fixing it but also dealing with the consequences of bad and badly enforced laws. We want a minimum wage so we go after the only person paying someone, the boss, and demand that they pay more. If instead we paid a (temporary) UBI to bring up the compensation it wouldn't all fall on the business owner and we wouldn't have to force them to do it. We want morbidly obese people to be welcome on airplanes but we forbid the airline from charging them for all the seats they consume. If we want people to pick up the disabled, and not shirk the task, then we shouldn't stick them with the cost. We should act like adults and pay (directly) for what we want, what we feel is right - trip subsidies for medical reasons.
- ggggtez 6y agoAre we going to offer a "bonus" to drivers that offer to drive old people, because they may take a little longer to get in the car? If the difference between profit and ruin is an extra 60 seconds for someone to sit down, then maybe the real solution is to pay the drivers a living wage.
- jedberg 6y agoWell really they should pay the Uber driver until they passenger is fully departed, but right now passengers get upset if the driver doesn't end the ride the moment they arrive (and if they start the drive before actually departing), so the driver has to load and unload on their own time. I try to make up for it by telling the driver to start the ride the moment I walk up, and letting them know not to end the ride until I've left, but not everyone does that.
- hluska 6y agoI’ve got the gift of the gab and so I see this differently. If I had no scruples or morals and chose to drive Uber, I could make an obscene hourly wage simply by picking up elderly people and engaging them in conversation. Most phone scams rely upon preying upon vulnerable, lonely people like this so sadly, it’s a public 0 day with no known fix.
- jedberg 6y agoI would argue that you're providing the service of companionship and should be paid for that too. :)
- hluska 6y agoYou know friend, I read enough comments from you to recognize you by name. You’ve always struck me as just an incredibly nice person. Thanks for this reply and for being such an all around good person. Hearing you talk on this thread is actually heartwarming - your respect and kindness are just incredible. Have an amazing evening!!!
- dillondoyle 6y agoMy Uber in Denver has Uber Pet. I thought I remembered seeing child seat in the past, maybe Ski too but I could be wrong.
- URSpider94 6y agoGuide dogs aren't pets. They are medical equipment.
- dillondoyle 6y agoit definitely looks like it's for pets here is what I see: https://imgur.com/a/apOq0TA https://imgur.com/a/apOq0TA the guide dogs should be allowed, at least that's what the article is about basically
- URSpider94 6y agoIf Uber Pet costs any more than just Uber, then it’s not ok for guide dog owners. You can’t charge a surcharge for transporting a service animal.
- dillondoyle 6y agowe are saying the same things
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- christkv 6y agoCheck out the mifold chair for kids it’s great for when you have to use taxis or a rental car https://www.mifold.com/ https://www.mifold.com/ it just simplified travel so much for us.
- jedberg 6y agoWe have a mifold for the older kid, but the younger one still needs a full carseat. When they were infants it was easier because I could strap them into the seat before the car arrived, and then just quickly buckle the seat in. But in the 11mo-3 year range, I need a full carseat that has to be installed before I can strap anyone in. :(
- loco5niner 6y agoPeople allergic to dogs should also get consideration though, and have the ability to reject a ride with a service animal. The ADA should protect both sides.
- jedberg 6y agoIt does though. If your allergy is so severe that you can’t accept a dog, then you can sue Uber too.