3 ms·
IANAL, but there is definitely such a thing as commercial fair use. The music industry is rife with "they stole my riff" cases that hinge on whether the copying
by shadowgovt 6y ago
IANAL, but there is definitely such a thing as commercial fair use. The music industry is rife with "they stole my riff" cases that hinge on whether the copying was transformative and the amount that was copied. I wouldn't go so far as to say this undermines the rule of law (rather, the Court's precedent-setting power is part of the rule of law. It may undermine rule by Congress, but nothing about the US system makes Congress a king, and if they want to take back their power on this topic, they need only craft a clearer law addressing these issues directly).
I think reasonable people can agree with Justice Thomas on this (sidebar: this is why I love reading SCOTUS rulings - they're generally wise people and both the majority and dissent sides are usually reasonable takes). The tests of "is it transformative" and "how much was taken" are probably the most subjective tests in the copyright precedent.