3 ms·
And OpenJDK is GPLv2 with a classpath exception. So why is Google unable to use Java's API here while Oracle able to use Amazon's API?
by jcranmer 6y ago
And OpenJDK is GPLv2 with a classpath exception. So why is Google unable to use Java's API here while Oracle able to use Amazon's API?
- tephra 6y agoIIRC (this case has been going on for way to long) they didn't cope the GPLed version of the code (oracle/sun had another proprietary version).
- jcranmer 6y agoSo the original case had claims against copying more of the original Sun JVM code than just the API--the entire furor over "rangeCheck" was a key part of the original case. By the first appeal, this was reduced to a de minimis claim of copyright and Oracle no longer pursued claims of copyright on anything but the API. My understanding is that all of the APIs in question are shared between the (now-Oracle) JVM and the OpenJDK implementation. (Indeed, I think the actual implementation of the Java code in question is the same between the closed and open source versions, it's only the JVM itself that differs.)
- fX0rObfoMN4 6y agoI thought this case is from back when Android was using Apache Harmony?
- kaba0 6y agoBecause it wasn’t GPLv2 at the time, and Sun explicitly disallowed mobile use?
- iam-TJ 6y agoGoogle used the Apache Harmony version as the basis for Android (Until Nougat). Some of the argument was over whether the Apache licence inherited by Google from Harmony was valid, or whether Harmony itself was in breach of copyright (and therefore had no valid licence Google could use). Once the courts decided APIs are copyrightable the argument switched to whether Google's was Fair-Use, with a jury saying it was, federal appeals court saying no, and thus it ended up at the Supreme court. Here's a Groklaw [0] copy of an early (April 2012) Oracle argument asking for Jury instructions around the licence topic that explains it well: "As made clear by Apache itself, Apache never had a license from Sun or Oracle for Harmony. Apache had no rights to Java technology that it could give to Google" [0] http://groklaw.net/pdf3/OraGoogle-959.pdf http://groklaw.net/pdf3/OraGoogle-959.pdf