3 ms·
Thomas's analysis pretty much starts from the conclusion that Google made billions off of Android, so therefore how could anything it be copied be fair use? He
by jcranmer 6y ago
Thomas's analysis pretty much starts from the conclusion that Google made billions off of Android, so therefore how could anything it be copied be fair use? He cloaks this analysis somewhat by arguing that the distinction between declaring and implementing code must be meaningless because Congress didn't lay it out explicitly in law, but for the person who actually broached the question of what other factors might influence fair use during oral arguments, it's pretty unintrospective about the analysis itself.
- tantalor 6y agoThe argument from the text could go the other way: Congress didn't mention declarative code in the copyright act, so it's not included.
- 1980phipsi 6y agoThomas says the copyright act says any computer code called directly or indirectly. The Thomas argument is that this is an indirect use of code.
- tantalor 6y agoThomas doesn't understand basic computer programming, so I wouldn't put much weight on that nuanced view. "Indirect" here just means calling a function or jumping to some address, rather than directly inlining some statements. For the purpose of copyright, the term "computer code" does not include the signature of that function, or the address you jump to, only the actual code statements at that destination.
- wslack 6y agoWhich, I would argue, is out of step with how that language was understood at the time the legislation was drafted.
- InsaneOstrich 6y agoHe probably owns a bunch of Oracle stock
- jcranmer 6y agoJustices routinely recuse themselves if they own stock in a company arguing before the court.
- paulmd 6y agoThomas didn't recuse himself when ruling on court cases filed by the advocacy group his wife is a leader of. It's all voluntary, if a Supreme Court justice chooses not to recuse themselves there is no higher court to force them.
- ncmncm 6y agoThomas aggressively refuses to recuse himself from cases that other justices consider an obvious conflict of interest. But they have no authority to enforce their opinion, and Thomas absolutely doesn't care. He didn't become a judge to rule on things he has no opinion on. For him, conflicting interest makes it that much more important to keep his hands in.
- astrange 6y agoNote, a lot of these "x legislator owns y stock" stories actually turn out to mean "x legislator owns a whole market index fund".
- rodgerd 6y agoIf I were attributing bad faith to Thomas - and given that he ignores court norms on recusing himself, that doesn't seem like too much of a stretch - I would be more likely to ascribe to him a desire to see "liberal Silicon Valley" punished than anything else. Thomas is an incredibly political beast, to the point that Scalia wrote him off as an unprincipled nutjob.