3 ms·
Just added a couple of MG07ACA14TA's to my NAS, as one of the two 8TB WD Reds I had started to fail after just 3 years of on time. They're massive beasts, with
by magicalhippo 6y ago
Just added a couple of MG07ACA14TA's to my NAS, as one of the two 8TB WD Reds I had started to fail after just 3 years of on time.
They're massive beasts, with 9 platters and 18 heads, but enabling acoustics and power saving really helped on the seeking noise level.
Not sure how much of a performance hit that leads to though, haven't had time to fully investigate.
They run significantly cooler than the 8TB Reds tho, from ~45C down to ~30C in the same bays.
- bscphil 6y ago> but enabling acoustics and power saving really helped on the seeking noise level. Do you know what's the approximate power draw (in Watts) of each drive with these settings enabled? I'd like to move to a lower power system sometime in the next year, but I'll also need to add some more drives. Power is extremely expensive where I live. I wonder if the power saving features reduce the drive lifetimes (because of quicker spindowns)... might not be a good idea for an always on NAS.
- magicalhippo 6y ago> Do you know what's the approximate power draw (in Watts) of each drive with these settings enabled? I do not, but I could find out as I have a external SATA to USB adapter with separate 12V power. Check back in a day or so. > I wonder if the power saving features reduce the drive lifetimes (because of quicker spindowns) Ah, I enabled max power-saving without spindown. Most of my earlier HD failures, including a couple of WD Greens, taught me to avoid spinning down.
- magicalhippo 6y agoSo I just recalled I had a DC-capable clamp meter, and I was able to isolate the disk on the last stretch of a power connector chain. I tried running with both the power management set to "Level 128 - Minimum power usage without Standby (no spindown)" and Acoustics Managment to "Maximum", as well as "Disabled" for both. Didn't make a noticeable difference on power draw, at most 0.1A more during writes, primarily just noise. Idle 5V 0.27A 12V 0.40A Write 5V 0.53A 12V 0.50A So that's just over 6W idle and 8.7W under load. I'm surprised about the high idle draw, both due to being significantly higher than the specs[1] and due to them running so cool. Did they spin down the disks to get the 4W figure perhaps? I did check my clamp meter against my electronic load and it reads pretty accurate. I didn't manage to test reads properly, since the disks are part of a ZFS pool and it spreads the reads all over, along with aggressive caching. [1]: https://toshiba.semicon-storage.com/us/storage/product/data-center-enterprise/cloud-scale-capacity/articles/mg07acaxxx.html https://toshiba.semicon-storage.com/us/storage/product/data-...
- bscphil 6y agoThanks for testing! That does seem kinda high. Western Digital has the following figures for 14 TB WD Reds: Read/Write – 6.2 W Idle – 3.0 W Standby and sleep - 0.8 W Which strikes me as pretty reasonable. I suppose I'll stick with those since I can rip them out of EasyStores.
- magicalhippo 6y agoToshiba datasheet says 8.1W under Q1 4k random R/W, I did my testing with streaming writes and queue depth around 10, so my write figure seems reasonable. For idle the datasheet says 4.53W typical, however I admit my disks were idle only for a few minutes when I did my readings as dinner was almost ready, so possible they would go lower after longer idle periods.
- nicolaslem 6y agoI recently built a NAS that sits 50cm away from me so noise was my #1 priority. During my research I realized that there are really two types of NAS drives: - the enterprise ones that are meant to sit in a datacenter. They offer the best performance but are noisy and power hungry. - the SOHO ones, that are often 5400 rpm. They are lower performance but optimized for noise and power consumption. I ended up with ST6000VN001 and the noise level is very reasonable.
- magicalhippo 6y agoYeah my NAS is also 50cm away from me. After changing the acoustics and getting rid of the WD Reds, my NAS is now actually more quiet. And thanks to the better thermals, due to the helium, I can reduce fan speeds significantly as well.
- purplecats 6y ago3 years seems like a very short shelf life for a HD. You seem reasonably happy with it. Was it expected?
- magicalhippo 6y agoI'm not terribly happy with the 8TB Red model, given it only lasted 3 years. It's also been fairly noisy and running hot. I have eight 3TB Reds, so far I've had two of those developing pending sectors after over 6 years of power-on time (no spindown), and of those one developed uncorrectable sectors a year later and I replaced it. The other one is chugging along happily so far with 27 pending sectors. In the case of the WD Red, it went from pending sectors to failing SMART self tests in less than two weeks. So yeah, disappointed about the short life span.
- purplecats 6y agoI have a fanton drives 2tb HDD model from like 2010. i dont use it frequently. it seems to run fine to this day. however, if its going to die soon, will it give me signs of failure, or will it just completely lock my data one day? i would like to get a replacement at the earliest sign, but idk how these things die.
- nahtnam 6y agoHow do you lower the acoustics and enable power saving? I have WD Reds and they are super loud and annoying
- magicalhippo 6y agoI use TrueNAS, it has it as part of the disk settings. For Linux it seems hdparm[1] is the way to go. [1]: https://linuxconfig.org/how-to-reduce-hard-drive-s-acoustic-noise-level https://linuxconfig.org/how-to-reduce-hard-drive-s-acoustic-...