4 ms·
Why would another country, especially one that's doing just fine like Ireland, want to eliminate a competitive edge it has?
by fortran77 6y ago
Why would another country, especially one that's doing just fine like Ireland, want to eliminate a competitive edge it has?
- coliveira 6y agoBecause the US has atomic bombs.
- secfirstmd 6y agoYes because the US is really going to threaten Ireland with atomic bombs...
- coliveira 6y agoEverything the US does has the implicit threat of atomic bombs. Or at least economic sanctions.
- pietrovismara 6y agoI don't get the downvotes. Thats exactly how it goes, how the US in the past retained the "first global power" trophy it now lost.
- viraptor 6y agoDownvoted a tone-deaf comment which puts together an implicit threat of instantly vaporising thousands of unsuspecting people, and refusing to do business in one sentence - as if there wasn't a massive difference. When someone writes "threat of atomic bombs" they should consider if they mean it.
- lucian1900 6y agoThere is a spectrum of violence the US can perpetrate, it starts with sanctions, continues with coups and invasions and ends with nukes. Sadly, we’ve seen the entirety of the spectrum already.
- peteretep 6y agoSo it doesn’t get locked out of the financial system by America
- akmarinov 6y agoThat’ll erode america’s financial system fairly quickly. You can’t sanction Ireland, without sanctioning the EU, also China and India won’t agree to that, so there goes 80% of the people you trade with.
- peteretep 6y agoWhy do you think the rest of the EU wouldn’t be on board? Nobody in the EU is happy with Ireland’s corp tax rate. China’s corp tax is 25%, India’s is complicated but around the same (in practice), PRC and India don’t want its rich people and global corps abusing tax shelters either.
- NwtnsMthd 6y agoHow does something like this generally work? Is it as simple as sanctions and/or tariffs?
- secfirstmd 6y agoYeh especially when in reality Ireland is open about stuff whereas many other counties do it through the backdoor. Places like the US and UK give huge benefits to companies but many of them are less direct. Write-offs, overlooking offshoring, R&D etc
- pietrovismara 6y agoBased on how the US behaves generally, just sanction them to hell. You don't want to apply the global tax rate? Have fun finding liquidity when every financial institution denies you access. It worked in reducing socialist countries to poverty, it will work in forcing the hand of fiscal paradises. Or is economical warfare fine only when it's used against the commies?
- Kim_Bruning 6y agoSo, this is why we have things like the European Union. It's to prevent global hegemons from hegemonizing TOO much. Sanction one member, and the other members could retaliate en bloc. Therefore you can't afford to sanction any single member. This means everyone who deals with EU members is forced to play fair game (give or take a lot of give and take; this is politics, after all). [Of course the other EU members aren't entirely pleased with Irish and Dutch corporate tax rates either, but that's a story for another thread]
- africanboy 6y agobecause the housing price bubble already hit hard Ireland in the recent past and it's gonna hit again soon if nothing changes. low corporate taxes have made Ireland a tax heaven, with all the drawbacks you can imagine Expensive housing, long commutes and stretched public services are making Ireland a less attractive place to live. And it’s not just younger people who feel aggrieved. People on relatively good incomes, who might have traditionally bought into the status quo, are now priced out and are calling for more radical solutions.
- lm28469 6y agoIt's not all rainbow and sunshine though. We should strive to work on a global level and not step on eachother with "competitive advantages" like these. These are only "competitive advantages" because some people high up decided they were legal (and probably gained some personal profit out of it). When starbucks, macdonalds or airbnb pay insanely low taxes in most european countries they're using legal ways to do so, but it doesn't benefits the people, it benefits the corporations. I personally don't care about the exact percentage of tax we should apply, but we should start by making them pay taxes in the countries the money is made and stop allowing companies to bend the rules so much. This is like dumping, it's a "competitive advantage" until you decide it's illegal or at least regulated, these things aren't written in stone