4 ms·
Any examples of the big time deliveries? Except the stock prices and cryptocoins? I think his first big time delivery of something revolutionary is about to be
by mrtksn 6y ago
Any examples of the big time deliveries? Except the stock prices and cryptocoins? I think his first big time delivery of something revolutionary is about to be StarLink.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI see quite a few people driving Teslas, and as I understand, SpaceX has successfully launched a few times.
- mrtksn 6y agoI see a lot more driving Toyota Corollas. Making a car is not a new thing, even electric cars are nothing new. And as for Space X, space travel is also nothing new. We have been traveling to space since 60 years and vertical landing and reusable space vehicles had been done before. All these stuff is simply re-do of the stuff humans did in the past but failed commercially. As I said, Musk is brilliant in building commercial systems. This time we have better cheaper technology and these things can actually be feasible.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoHow are Corollas relevant to this discussion? If you think scaling up a car manufacturer to becoming a mainstream brand is not “delivering big time”, then I guess I will simply have to disagree. > All these stuff is simply re-do of the stuff humans did in the past but failed commercially. That was my point. At least some of Musks’s claims were based in reality and so he was able to deliver something. The entirety of Holmes’ claims were fictional. That’s the difference.
- mrtksn 6y agoBecoming a mainstream brand is definitely not a big delivery on the promise that in 2 years you will tell your electric car where you want to go and it will take you there without further input from you. As a financial delivery, sure. It turned out to be a good stock investment. So may others like AMD, Apple or GameStop. I don't argue that Musk can't make brands and money, he surely can.
- postingawayonhn 6y agoYou're running some very weird arguments here. Bringing costs down and volumes up are significant achievements in any industry. Sure there were a few other electric cars out there before Tesla but nothing with 500km range that was compelling and affordable to the middle classes. There were other rockets too but SpaceX significantly reduced cost and launch frequency. Nobody had recovered an orbital rocket before SpaceX, let alone reusing it another 7 times.
- mrtksn 6y agoI don't think that I argued against any of that, I don't know what do you expect me to say but I have to point out that the pace shuttles were re-used much more than 7 times. I'm sure that SpaceX will surpass these numbers some day, after all it's a work in progress as long as you don't accept that you failed. Space X is doing some cool stuff and spectacular videos.
- postingawayonhn 6y agoThe orbiters and solid boosters were but the massive external tank was not recovered. The time and complexity associated with the refurbishment of the orbiters and booters resulted in a program cost of over $1b per launch. SpaceX can launch similar sized payloads on FH for ~$150m.
- mrtksn 6y agonice factoid, thanks.
- tuatoru 6y ago> Any examples of the big time deliveries? Musk's biggest achievement is changing the Conventional Wisdom[1] of government policymakers in the west from "electric vehicles are a nice idea, but a toy for rich people" to "right, we're phasing out fossil fuel powered cars" in the space of a decade. That is something I did not expect to see in my lifetime. You will quibble that lots of other people did the technical work. But Musk had the public visibility. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conventional_wisdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conventional_wisdom
- cedilla 6y agoThat's a pretty wild statement, even if it was about Tesla instead of Musk. Especially considering that a ton of these policies are about as old as the Tesla roadster. Must be a hell of a achievement to change policy retroactively. The reason why we have an electronic car revolution now is because batteries have finally become cheap and dense enough. Maybe the largest manufacturer of EVs deserves some credit, but that's of course never been Tesla.
- tuatoru 6y ago> a ton of these policies are about as old as the Tesla roadster Then why did newspapers only report them in the last 18 months?
- cedilla 6y agoI don't know what newspapers you read. Even the Model S was wildly successfull by 2017. I certainly read about that car topping sales charts in Norway thanks to government subsidies in 2013 or so. There were government subsidies for EV cars more than 18 years ago, and they were almost everywhere 18 months ago. Anyway, what newspapers report and what's the "conventional wisdom of policymakers in the west" is unrelated, if we even accept that "the west" and "conventional wisdom of policymakers" aren't nebulous constructs.
- tuatoru 6y ago