4 ms·
> I bet Theranos could still be a thing today if Musk was the CEO instead of Holmes. How so? The very basis of what Holmes promised with Theranos is impossible
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
> I bet Theranos could still be a thing today if Musk was the CEO instead of Holmes.
How so? The very basis of what Holmes promised with Theranos is impossible based on current knowledge. Musk promised something that at least had a basis in reality, and could be worked on refined (not the autonomous driving, but an electric car).
Holmes just promised something arbitrary and then hoped for a scientific breakthrough.
- mrtksn 6y agoMusk is also hoping for scientific breakthrough. When the breakthrough is not there, he says it will be there in 2 years. What he does is nothing new, electric cars or vertically landing rockets, reusable space vehicles are not new but he is the only one who could manage to collect the funding necessary to work on these things again and be the one who is doing it with the current technology(which could end up financially sound this time). For example, hyperloop is proving to be total BS, no roots in reality. Just look what he promised and what he delivered. The trick to keep party going on, if the party is not over you don't fail. "Hyperloop delivered nothing" is a failure, "Hyperloop delivered something that is nothing that was promised but a car in a concrete tunnel, nice CGI and a model of what it could be" is work in progress. If you can keep the party going on for long enough, ether the technology will catch up or people will forget the original promise and accept the current delivery. Musk could end up being Tube magnate if he can keep up the funding despite not delivering on the vacuum tube hypersonic travel stuff.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Musk is also hoping for scientific breakthrough. When the breakthrough is not there, he says it will be there in 2 years. Yes, a lot of what he says is nonsense, like Holmes. But the difference is he also delivered big time on some of what he said. I assume many people are aware of his pie in the sky hopes for the future, but that is different from Holmes claiming she already had a technological breakthrough and succeeded in something all the other scientists with decades more experience knew wasn’t possible, and yet not providing any evidence.
- mrtksn 6y agoAny examples of the big time deliveries? Except the stock prices and cryptocoins? I think his first big time delivery of something revolutionary is about to be StarLink.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI see quite a few people driving Teslas, and as I understand, SpaceX has successfully launched a few times.
- mrtksn 6y agoI see a lot more driving Toyota Corollas. Making a car is not a new thing, even electric cars are nothing new. And as for Space X, space travel is also nothing new. We have been traveling to space since 60 years and vertical landing and reusable space vehicles had been done before. All these stuff is simply re-do of the stuff humans did in the past but failed commercially. As I said, Musk is brilliant in building commercial systems. This time we have better cheaper technology and these things can actually be feasible.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoHow are Corollas relevant to this discussion? If you think scaling up a car manufacturer to becoming a mainstream brand is not “delivering big time”, then I guess I will simply have to disagree. > All these stuff is simply re-do of the stuff humans did in the past but failed commercially. That was my point. At least some of Musks’s claims were based in reality and so he was able to deliver something. The entirety of Holmes’ claims were fictional. That’s the difference.
- mrtksn 6y agoBecoming a mainstream brand is definitely not a big delivery on the promise that in 2 years you will tell your electric car where you want to go and it will take you there without further input from you. As a financial delivery, sure. It turned out to be a good stock investment. So may others like AMD, Apple or GameStop. I don't argue that Musk can't make brands and money, he surely can.