4 ms·
> As a French coming from African descent I'm absolutely terrified of what they are going to do with character like Napoleon or Charles de Gaulle Could you ela
by pjc50 6y ago
> As a French coming from African descent I'm absolutely terrified of what they are going to do with character like Napoleon or Charles de Gaulle
Could you elaborate on this?
- f6v 6y agoThey'll get cancelled, or worse, a modern-day makeover.
- DetroitThrow 6y agoWhile I've read a bunch of critical media of de Gaulle, much of the media I've read of Napoleon seems to be tinged with his glory - I'd actually love a more critical review of historical Napoleon given his influence on modern Europe and the West at large.
- kazen44 6y agoNapoleon is kind of a.. controversial character in history. let's not forget that the late 18th century was a bloody period in european history with massive societal change. It saw the removal of old medieval systems and them being replaced by more modern ideas.
- DetroitThrow 6y agoOh, all the more reason for a more critical review of his legacy, I'm sure it'd be very interesting with a more objective/modern lens.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoAbsolutist monarchy is an (early) modern phenomenon, not a middle age one. Middle ages ended with the conquest of Constantinople by the Ottomans in 1453. In fact, wouldn't Napoleon be part (and the end ?) of the absolutist monarch phenomenon?
- pjc50 6y agoNapoleon was ""cancelled"" within his lifetime by being sent into exile. In Britain, his name used to be used as a shorthand for dictatorial behaviour, especially from short men. De Gaulle was again subject to what you might call the ""woke mob"" during his lifetime: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_68 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_68 People have to learn to cope with accurate presentation of what historical figures did, a lot of which was very bad especially for the losing side.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 6y agoWhat's with the double quotes? Of course we want an accurate portrayal of the character, the good and the bad. The worry is it won't be so accurate coming from a contemporary American perspective.
- walshemj 6y agoI think going to the barricades is a much older French tradition and labeling it with the modern "woke" label -does tend to indicate your politics.
- pjc50 6y agoThat's what the sarcasm quotes were for.
- watwut 6y agoYou know, he is not celebrated in places where he brought destruction with him. As in outlook on foreign army in more informed by pillaging then by glory. That is how countries typically interpret history - from their point of view.
- williamdclt 6y agoWhite Frenchman perspective: Napoleon and De Gaulle are characters that are usually viewed positively in France, they were important figures that did big things for the nation (such as freeing it from the nazis). But you don't need to scratch the surface very deep to see the dark side: imperialism, colonialism, racism, despotism... I don't particularly trust Netflix not to whitewash these leaders. It'd be easy to gloss over the not-so-shiny stuff and present them as one-sided heros to the French people, who are not always taught the dark side of their own history.
- rsynnott 6y agoFor Napoleon, I suspect there's not _that_ much danger of that, because if Netflix is developing a show to be shown all over Europe... well, Napoleon is somewhat less popular elsewhere in Europe. Just a bit.
- V-2 6y agoOf course, but not universally so. Eg. Napoleon's perception in Poland is very positive (including a favourable mention in the national anthem).
- watwut 6y agoWhen I went to France first time, I was surprised Napolen was celebrated. I was around the time people start high school. Here, he was basically mocked (over size etc). Because he went in, brought war with him, history books have people flying city when his army is comming and he blew the castle. So basically the history is only the negative, because foreign army matching through country means hunger and violence.
- filoleg 6y ago> he went in, brought war with him, history books have people flying city when his army is comming and he blew the castle. So basically the history is only the negative, because foreign army matching through country means hunger and violence. Not just that, but you also gotta remember his failed invasion of Russian Empire. He got cocky, went all-in, didn't realize how brutal winters there were, and didn't expect that Russian generals were more than willing to set their own cities/towns on fire just to not let Napoleon capture them. So in the end, he had to retreat back to France during winter. Which not only marked his invasion as a complete failure, but also humiliated him on top of it by making him lose a ton of his soldiers on the way back due to the weather.