5 ms·
And the US, sadly, becomes more like the developing world, every time I visit... Public infrastructure, decent wages, national health care, public transport, a
by coldtea 6y ago
And the US, sadly, becomes more like the developing world, every time I visit...
Public infrastructure, decent wages, national health care, public transport, and such ain't "beyond the pale" guys...
Though, to be frank, European politicians are influenced by this and want to bring more of it here faster. Private profit of the few above people, and let the suckers believe in wealth "trickling down"...
- rbanffy 6y agoCapitalism extracts work from wealth gradients the same way a Stirling engine extracts it from temperature ones. The higher the gradient, the more efficient it becomes.
- DetroitThrow 6y agoHaha, I wish this wasn't such a STEM-y analogy so I could mention it to my friends, it's great and describes so much in so little.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoIs it a pro and anti capitalism point, i cant tell. By that logic it was most efficient with slavery? And the next best thing with serfs?
- rbanffy 6y agoIt’s not pro or against. It’s an observation. Slavery and serfdom is not as efficient because the motivation to work is extrinsic and needs work to maintain.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's worse than that. Slaves will actively sabotage the work, even at the risk of execution when caught.
- hoophoop 6y ago> extracts work from wealth gradients That's an odd way to describe worker exploitation.
- f6v 6y ago> And the US, sadly, becomes more like the developing world, every time I visit... But Biden has the "once in a generation infrastructure plan"!
- WalterBright 6y agoThe homeless crisis in Seattle parallels the progressive rise to prominence in the city politics. All the city positions are occupied by progressives. Nobody else even bothers to run.
- frakkingcylons 6y agoThat’s a pretty dubious implication of causation.
- pessimizer 6y agoAnd the larger the safety net holes get, the more progressives will be elected, hopefully.
- asdff 6y agoLA has had every flavor of mayor over the last century, and Skid row has been Skid row ever since it was first named such in the early 1900s.
- weehoo 6y agoSkid is another word for shipping pallet and it’s called skid row because it’s next to the freight train lines into downtown. Pallets would get stacked high along the streets, hence skid row. There are plenty of cities across America with their own area called skid row. The name has nothing to do with the current homeless population. It is common for poor industrial areas to end up with large transient populations, but that’s a case of convergent evolution.
- reducesuffering 6y agoIf you're going to correct someone, isn't it worth spending just a few minutes doing due diligence? Skid row comes from logging roads where the logs were skidded down the road.[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skid_row https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skid_row
- asdff 6y agoIt's not named after homeless people, I'm saying the character of the place has been the same since like the 1890s. That part of town has always been full of transient and destitute people no matter the flavor of local government, is the point I was trying to make. The OP comment was implying some false correlation between homelessness and progressive government. Lest we forget it was progressive government initiatives that ended the great depression and both peace and wartime public works projects, not private corporations, that finally got people back to work decades ago.
- varispeed 6y agoWealth is not "trickling down" mainly because of high taxes in Europe. Corporations have incentive to transfer profits outside and spend it only when absolutely necessary, otherwise any bigger project wouldn't be economical. So not only those corporations act like a hoover of funds, the void that is created has to be filled with something - and here comes progressive tax, that ensures middle class cover what otherwise those big corporations would have to pay and also ensures that if someone comes from a poor background they almost never go up in the class ladder. This will eventually create a society where everyone cannot afford anything to buy, but they will be able to scrap money together to pay for subscriptions and big corporations will become de facto governments and all parliaments will focus on protecting that status quo rather than serving the public.
- rsynnott 6y agoWhile there are obviously major problems, if you rank countries by the social mobility indexes, or by GINI (income inequality) indexes, the top ten or so are all high-tax European countries. Mind you, there's more to it than that; just setting the high-income-band taxes high won't do it. Efficacy of taxation and control of corruption is also important. Ireland's an interesting case; in the 80s its income tax was quite high (and it was a substantial net beneficiary of EU funding) but its GINI index was the worst in the EU (it was actually worse than the US for part of the decade). Today, income tax is still quite high (though not as high), and it's a donor of EU funding, but the GINI index is middle of the road European, far better than it used to be. The main thing that changed, beyond overall economic development, is reduction of corruption; there's no point in having big high-income-band taxes if no-one pays them.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"Corporations have incentive to transfer profits" They will always have incentive to movw money into a tax heaven, their rate is zero
- BlueTemplar 6y agoOnly if the money can be freely moved.
- neither_color 6y agoSo visit a different part of it. As someone whose parents grew up without electricity in their home that's nonsense and tone deaf. We don't need an "America bad" melodrama on every thread, especially one about European culture. Turn off the news and talk to real people. You have no idea how positively we brown 1st and 2nd gen immigrants view America, and the pages I could write on how far ahead of the "developing" latin and South/Southeast Asian world it still is. And yes Ive been to 20+ countries I'm not missing "perspective". Europeans have certain benefits explicitly defined by law and we don't because the US is rooted in a libertarian understanding of what a "right" is but we get them anyway and to keep it brief I will say that the recent hyper-focus on the US' flaws and fixation on what other countries "promise" their citizens make people myopic to how it actually plays out in the real world. I've met many entrepreneurial Spanish, Dutch, Norwegian, French, and Australian friends abroad on the nomad circuits who start their own cafes and training centers and studios in other countries and tell me about what they lack back home and went in search of outside of the EU. I'm much more appreciative of the opportunities the US still offers after having traveled.
- coldtea 6y ago>So visit a different part of it. With this mindset soon there wont be any left. >As someone whose parents grew up without electricity in their home that's nonsense and tone deaf. (...) You have no idea how positively we brown 1st and 2nd gen immigrants view America It's easy to view the current status positively if you start from a low bar. But sure, the US has electricy AND running water. I'll give you that. Well, mostly ( https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/26/how-texas-tough-winter-exposed-us-power-grid-problems-.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/26/how-texas-tough-winter-expos... ).
- vinay427 6y agoSecond-generation Americans almost universally didn't start from a low bar themselves. Many first-generation Americans didn't start from a low bar, either, but that's maybe a different point.
- mbrodersen 6y ago