6 ms·
As a European, this article is the degree of pretentious, market-driven, and shallow, that fits perfectly with the Economist. "Streaming subtitled box sets" ar
by coldtea 6y ago
As a European, this article is the degree of pretentious, market-driven, and shallow, that fits perfectly with the Economist.
"Streaming subtitled box sets" are not "the new Eurovision", and Eurovision itself meant and means squat when it comes to "common European culture". (If anything Eurovision is something most of us watch for laughs, and more often than not we take sides and vote for countries we already knew and liked for other cultural and historical reasons).
We have had and have a quite good understanding of other European states and their cultures, even more so when they share the same borders (as it's often the case in Europe - to have 2, 3 or more countries sharing your borders and have millenia of interaction with them and their culture, plus "shared" areas of mixed culture, e.g. Strasbourg).
It's not the lack of Netflix's European programming or watching each other's shows that prevented a "common European culture".
Not to mention, we have had something like that, both in the high-brow sphere (for centuries), but also in the pop-culture.
E.g. non-artsy Italian and French cinema from Alain Delon to Bud Spenser was big all-over Europe until the 80s when Hollywood dominated with emphasis on impossible to meet big productions and vfx. European pop music frequently travelled all over Europe, from Al Bano to Roussos and from Nina Hagen to Kraftwerk. Comics too, French, English, Italian, Belgian, Spanish (to namedrop some that were published and loved all over Europe: Asterix, Tin Tin, Mortadelo y Filemon, Lucky Luke, Blek, Judge Dredd, the Smurfs, Manara, Corto Maltese, and so on).
And as somebody mentioned, Interrail and Erasmus have been going strong for 3 to 4 decades now or more... (I've done the first, and have had many friends doing both the first and the second.).
- Gwypaas 6y agoYes, for example the grand tour which many young upper class people went on in the 17th and 18th century. With the explicit goal to expose themselves to as much culture and other elite people around the continent as possible. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Tour https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Tour
- pjc50 6y agoFar more recently than that, Interrail and the Erasmus scheme. The UK withdrew from the Erasmus scheme as part of Brexit seemingly for no other reason than to discourage cultural integration.
- krona 6y agoThe Turing scheme will probably be more attractive to UK students because it will likely include more countries that UK students are actually interested in experiencing.
- rover0 6y agoDoes not look that good https://twitter.com/maxfras/status/1368913490308702208?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1368913490308702208%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.redditmedia.com%2Fmediaembed%2Fm0gdie%3Fresponsive%3Dtrueis_nightmode%3Dfalse https://twitter.com/maxfras/status/1368913490308702208?ref_s... The missing tuition support is really harsh, especially if Turing is for the US
- KaiserPro 6y agosupposedly, students don't pay tuition fees, because universities are expected to partner to waive fees. I don't see this working in all honesty.
- vinay427 6y agoThis tuition agreement which is often implemented as a waiver (so the student pays at most their home rate) is already the case for many exchange programs which have existed between innumerable university-pairs for many years. I don't see why the Turing program approach wouldn't be feasible.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JetSetWilly 6y ago> The UK withdrew from the Erasmus scheme as part of Brexit seemingly for no other reason than to discourage cultural integration. I think it was because of two reasons. First, the sort of people who go on Erasmus and Interrail tend to be the sort of people who could have afforded it anyway - it is a subsidy for the well to do. And secondly, far fewer people go from the UK to other countries, than come from other countries to come here, so it is a financial drain. You could argue that it was a good idea for soft power reasons for the UK to do, but it doesn't seem to have built up a lot of European good will so far and perhaps the government has reasoned that the money is better spent elsewhere.
- fireattack 6y agoWhat is "high-bro sphere"? I googled and didn't find anything.
- dudeinjapan 6y agoI think he's referring to this guy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAhM0nds2UY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAhM0nds2UY
- effie 6y agoWow, how does he make that ball and coin levitate. Is this a CGI prank?
- dudeinjapan 6y agoNo it's not CGI. Here's another view and you can see at 7:00 he does a similar setup where there's a large ball placed on his head which he removes before doing the smaller floating ball, which gives him some excuse to touch his head. I'm guessing there is an invisible string dangling down off his forehead because the ball always floats in alignment with his head. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUqHLeXeecY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUqHLeXeecY
- effie 6y agoYou're definitely on to something. In both videos he touches his head and then spins the small ball. Still the execution is amazing.
- tim333 6y agoI think he means highbrow as in opera, Dante etc. I quite like the article and found it interesting. I'm a Brit and you have to realize British publications like the Economist tend to take the piss out of Europe a bit, especially the Eurovision song contest.
- oblio 6y ago
- Veen 6y agoI stream a lot of French and other European shows, and it's primarily because I'm bored with American and (especially) BBC TV. But, as you say, it's nothing new. I've read translated French and German literature all my life. I've long enjoyed French, Polish, and Hungarian cinema. So have most of the people I know (including those who were pro-Brexit). I enjoy it precisely because, although Europe shares a fair bit of culture, these works are not the product of a homogenized Mid-Atlantic or "common European" culture, but an expression of the particular culture, xplace, and time in which they was made.
- bobthechef 6y agoYeah, these sorts of "arguments" are typical of either those who wish for Europe to have a common culture (like EU federalist extremists) or people who don't have a genuine common culture like Americans, but think they do. Both fail to grasp the reality of culture and end up trivializing it to great detriment for everyone (the Soviets tried the same and it all came crashing down as Soviet Man led to the return of the repressed ethnic identities of the Russian Empire). The former trivialize it, thinking they can magically manufacture some kind of common identity (What the heck is "European" identity? Common cultural features or foundations, much less the suppression of diversity, do not suffice to magically produce an ethnic or cultural identity). I suspect EU federalists think they can replicate the kind of rootless Americanism that was produced by identity theft and makes people vulnerable to manipulation (the dissolution of European ethnic neighborhoods was largely the product of social engineering that attempted to assimilate these people into a manufactured, imposed, and ultimately vacuous "white" identity and you can see this because most European immigrants weren't white until much later in American history. I mean, what the heck is "white" identity? It's ultimately meaningless and allows those in power to fill it with any content they like, like "person who drinks Coke, watches Hollywood movies, and buys tons of crap he doesn't need, oh, and accepts abuse from a usurious oligarchy that uses debt and compound interest as an instrument of power and enrichment"). This is part of the reason why Americans are so confused about such things because they have no real culture. Why would you want to inflict something like that on Europe? Besides, ethnic difference is interesting and need not be a source of hatred or conflict. You need some way to simultaneously keep your ethnicity and transcend it. Every attempt to go to the extremes, to exaggerate ethnicity or so suppress it, always lead to disaster. All of this is not to say that TV cannot be used as a powerful tool for social engineering. It can and it is. Television and Hollywood have, in concert with the education system, caused enormous changes in society. It's just harder to accomplish without first demoralizing and robbing someone of his identity first. Solve et coagula.
- pera 6y ago> As a European, this article is the degree of pretentious, market-driven, and stupid, that fits perfectly with the Economist. Almost every time I read an article from The Economist I see that many of their arguments are founded on false premises which are (usually) trivial to fact-check. I really don't get why this publication gets posted here on HN so often.
- varispeed 6y agoThe seem to be publishing what most people want to hear and as such it is pleasing to many people, regardless whether it is true or not. They just want to feel good for a moment and escape the reality.
- jimnotgym 6y agoThe Economist has a variety of types of article. It has a World news round up. It has short opinion pieces (like the ones that get shared here) and longer form in depth analysis sections. It finishes with Arts and culture science and obituaries. I have only ever seen the short (1/2 to 1 page in the printed version) opinion pieces shared here. I think most publications could be judged unfairly by reading the only those parts. Usually the magazine is themed on one subject for the week and publishes a range of angles on the same thing. Again sharing one part of it rather destroys the beauty of it. I think that is why I can't get on with the digital editions. I was a subscriber to the paper edition, but it is supposed to arrive Saturday morning in the mail, but often didn't. I found thay if it arrived on Monday I was only finding time to flick through it.
- willyt 6y agoThis happens with other papers as well. It's always the opinion pieces that get shared because they press people's buttons. Then everyone piles on with 'Oh this isn't journalism' obviously! of course it's not, it's usually not written by a journalist and it's not meant to be journalism. I can understand how people that didn't grow up with the print editions can get confused though as I've noticed that Apple News puts lots of opinion pieces in my 'news' feed and because of the diversity of sources it's not always easy to tell as there are no strong visual clues and each outlet's conventions for opinion pieces are different and I think they call them something different in America, I forget the word, (editorial?).
- paganel 6y agoSpot on. I think that nowadays Champions League football (and European football in general) has done more to create a common European identity/culture than all the top-down measures implemented by various institutions, you can have a Romanian and a Swede both saying they’re a Madridista or a Scouse while having no other interest in the Spanish and British cultures. Re: Italian music, I still have a couple of Ornella Vanoni and Mina CDs in my car, it’s the only thing that I listen while on road-trips (am Romanian).
- coldtea 6y agoHuh, football of course. I only forgot it because I'm not a big fan, but as far as "common European thing / knowledge of each other countries aspects" comes, it has historically been huge!
- andrepd 6y agoAnother benefit of football is that in channels all that aggressiveness and fanatic nationalisms into a harmless sport.
- eisa01 6y agoEurovision may be more for laughs today, but I believe it historically had a different position? From watching it in the 90's as a child, I don't remember it being near as crazy as today, and they started in the 1950's
- hencq 6y agoIt's been pretty camp for a long time though. As a European living in the US I got a good laugh when my American friends watched the Will Ferrell movie "Eurovision". Especially when I got to explain to them that it wasn't even all that exaggerated and some of the characters were actually real-life former contestants.
- the_af 6y ago> to namedrop some that were published and loved all over Europe: Asterix, Tin Tin, Mortadelo y Filemon, Lucky Luke, Blek, Judge Dredd, the Smurfs, Manara, Corto Maltese, and so on Many of these were loved in Latin America as well. Lucky Luke and Asterix are my personal favorites, though there's a special place for Corto Maltese (Hugo Pratt is revered in my country) and I also liked Manara for erotic comics. To this day I consider European comics way superior to American comics, where superheroes tended to dominate. Yes, I do love Sandman and Robert Crumb, of course.
- runarberg 6y agoA Donald Duck fan here: It is funny to mention that Donald Duck is way more popular in Europe then in his place of origin in North America. Several European publishers had (have?) authors on staff and share stories with other European publishers. Se we got (get?) stories that the Americans don’t get. Also in the nineties the translation in my home country was exceptionally good. When I talk about Donald Duck with Americans they don’t get it, but when I talk with other Europeans there is a long and fun conversation ahead. I always think it is cute when a work of art travels from the place of origin and shines in a different part of the world in this way.
- the_duke 6y agoIn general I agree, but I also have a counter point. I enjoy the European shows on Amazon and Netflix, much more so than the tiring Hollywood garbage. Netflix does bring a decent budget for more Hollywood competitive production value to shows that feel distinctively less "US", which is a good thing for Europe, or at least provides a distribution platform to increase revenue for local shows. Of course many of those shows also are produced for selling to a global audience, and French or some other local productions are more valuable for a European culture. But the contribution is not zero or negative. German shows were especially horrible (no, really, horrible) until very recently.
- mschuster91 6y ago> E.g. non-artsy Italian and French cinema from Alain Delon to Bud Spenser was big all-over Europe until the 80s when Hollywood dominated with emphasis on impossible to meet big productions and vfx. It's not impossible to meet Hollywood's financial power, also its artistic power... Germany alone for example has producers (Constantin Film), studios (Bavaria, Babelsberg), VFX shops (Scanline, Stargate, Pixomondo) or tech rental (ARRI), and not to mention all the locations which many US blockbusters regularly use. The core difference America has and what makes Hollywood so dominant is that everything except locations is pretty much concentrated in Hollywood (with Vancouver and Toronto offshoots in Canada), whereas in Europe everything is splintered - Germany alone has Cologne, Berlin and Munich. That makes it harder for all parties involved in a production (please don't get me started on the disgrace that is high-speed internet connectivity here) and, crucially, we don't have the informal "network effects" resulting from having everyone drink at the same bars in one town. If anyone, be it a billionaire or a government, in Europe were to fund a "cinema town" modeled after Hollywood, inter-European infighting would kill the project before it even had a chance at getting started. We can't even get our heavy industry companies merged so that they're sizable enough to fight against Chinese and US companies - how are we supposed to successfully do that for a industry that doesn't have much economic relevance?
- corty 6y agoWell, there are attempts, especially in France, to pick national champions in different industries and concentrate public funding on them to build up companies that are relevant on the international stage. This has also been tried on a (somewhat) European (but still French-dominated) scale with Airbus and Arianespace. But I think most other European governments view these kinds of activities rather suspiciously.