3 ms·
When a person submits their phone number to this website, the website operator can immediately search Facebook for the user name associated with the phone numbe
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
When a person submits their phone number to this website, the website operator can immediately search Facebook for the user name associated with the phone number. No need to save the phone numbers. He can turn them into user names. Edit: Not suggesting the website operator is doing that, but the point is he could.
https://mbasic.facebook.com/login/identify/?ctx=recover https://mbasic.facebook.com/login/identify/?ctx=recover
- cantrevealname 6y ago> website operator can immediately search Facebook for the user name I’m not seeing that. If Facebook recognizes the phone number, it offers to send an SMS to that number or to send an email to an obfuscated email address (like r***@***). At most, you learn that the user’s email starts with an “r” as in example above. And possibly the numbers of letters in the username, but my experiments indicate that Facebook is not telling you the precise number of asterisks to deduce the length. Maybe when you tried it, you were using a known device (eg., having an IP address from which you logged into Facebook on an earlier occasion), and therefore Facebook was offering you more detail, such as your username. Could you try a random phone number from the 533M leaked numbers and see if you still get the username?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoYes, the results will vary depending on IP+device fingerprint. At a minimum, what this search allows is confirmation that a phone nnumber is associated with an existing Facebook account.
- davidjohnstone 6y agoInteresting, I didn't know you could do that. When I write "I'm not saving the phone number you enter" I mean to convey the idea that I'm not doing anything else with that number. As far as I know, the number and any derivative products of that number only exists inside the request context and are not stored in any way. There could be bugs, or I could be lying, but I'm not doing anything underhanded like that.
- daniellarusso 6y agoIf you are using POST over https, that should be fine. But, if it is GET requests in the URL over http, yeah, that is leaving a trail. Any 3rd party JS analytics has access to everything, though.
- supernova87a 6y agoBut it appears he is not doing that. I was able to search the phone number of someone I know, and it was confirmed to be in the breached data. However, it is not present in your above password reset / recovery link. On the other hand, it is for some others I tested.