8 ms·
I mean, Starship exists and with each (frequent) test flight it gets closer to delivering on the promise of full reusability, which is jet-age-level shit. F9 i
by sneak 6y ago
I mean, Starship exists and with each (frequent) test flight it gets closer to delivering on the promise of full reusability, which is jet-age-level shit.
F9 is also incredible and has made the impossible possible... and Starlink is one instance of that, which also exists and is usable.
You can't really highlight his failures without also giving credit where credit is due to his (and his organizations') successes.
I'm really curious how he gets such smart and talented people to work at his companies.
- mdbug 6y agoFact check: Starship has been in development for about 8 years, has exploded on every landing so far, and has never reached orbit.
- sneak 6y agoThat's not true, one exploded before landing a few days ago. :P
- erikstarck 6y agoUhm. Yeah, prototypes of the next general vessel have exploded while gathering data. Meanwhile, Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy have made numerous successful and commercial launches and landings.
- mdbug 6y agoI don't want to deny the successes at all. But everything SpaceX has achieved so far was possible before. I guess the statement that Starship is getting closer to its promise can be expressed that way, but it almost sounds like it's already close and in reality it's far from being ready. Also consider that it took NASA about 9 years to fully develop the Space Shuttle from ground up and they didn't lose a single vehicle during testing - 50 years ago!
- chrisco255 6y agoNo, they lost one when it mattered most: when humans were on board. Besides, Starship is meant as more of a replacement for Apollo than for the shuttle.
- mdbug 6y agoThis does not contradict what I wrote.
- chrisco255 6y agoIt's not a contradiction what I wrote, it's a fair point. Two of the five shuttles eventually exploded with passengers on board. Better to learn the hard edge cases in testing.
- mdbug 6y agoYou probably shouldn't have started the sentence with "No" then, but never mind. Let's hope that space travel will be safer in the future. Anyway, I really just wanted to point out that 50 years ago it was apparently possible to develop spaceships in less time without a "move fast and break things" approach.
- tim333 6y agoThe Apollo program cost about $156 billion in modern money. Starship's approach is very cheap in comparison. Must estimates about $5bn.
- mahkeiro 6y agoCorrection they lost 2 shuttles not one
- sneak 6y ago> But everything SpaceX has achieved so far was possible before. This is not accurate: reusable orbital first stages is a SpaceX first, and the cost savings it yielded enabled Starlink, which is another SpaceX first (high speed, low-latency, low-altitude LEO satellite internet).
- tigershark 6y agoFact check: Starship was in development for much less time than SLS, it costs order of magnitudes less and it had several successful 10 km flights. Your comment is absolutely misleading if not outright false because starship as we know it with the steel construction is from end of 2018, so a little more than 2 years ago. The current testing pace is two launches in less than 30 days. SLS had a failed static fire in January and it took them 3 months just to do another static fire. Starship performs multiple static fires per day and it’s the only vehicle in history that managed to fly with full flow engines.
- postingawayonhn 6y agoRaptor may have begun development for 8 years but Starship has only been in full development for about 3 years.
- mgoetzke 6y agoAnd Raptor is an enormous achievement. A full-flow combustion engine that actually looks likely to be used.